Most helpful customer reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
Courtesy of Teens Read Too, April 6 2011
Ce commentaire est de: Toads and Diamonds (Hardcover)
Diribani and Tana both meet a goddess while fetching water from the town. She grants each sister a gift. When Diribani speaks, jewels and flowers fall from her mouth. When Tana speaks, toads and snakes fall from hers.
When their secret is discovered, it changes the sisters' lives. Diribani finds herself traveling with the Prince and his family. Each jewel is recorded and taken to send back to her village. She learns a new set of customs but struggles to keep part of herself intact.
Tana's gift brings fear. She, too, leaves her home and travels to a monastery. Before long, she sets off on a pilgrimage to learn the true meaning of her gift. Her travels bring her grief, and destruction follows in her path.
Are their gifts a blessing or a curse?
A wonderful fairy tale consisting of two sisters, with alternating chapters of each one's story. As each sister struggles to understand her gift, they encounter danger, friendship, romance, hardships, joy, tests of their strength, and a strong desire to see her sister.
Reviewed by: Jennifer Rummel
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent take on a less well known tale, April 9 2011
By Serena F. "Firesong" - Published on Amazon.com
Ce commentaire est de: Toads and Diamonds (Hardcover)
I admit it: I chose this book by its cover, at my local library. But it lived up to my hopes. I like the use of a fairy tale not covered by Disney. I appreciate the South Asian setting that provides a refreshing change of scene, as well as a reason for people to perceive the ability to conjure snakes and toads as blessing rather than a curse. I like that the stepsisters love each other and their mother/stepmother instead of being rivals as in a traditional fairy tale.
The plot offers plenty of adventure. The details of the setting give a nice view of a fascinating culture. The main characters are richly depicted; their thoughts sound realistic for young women. Tana's tendency to put herself down and Diribati's occasional daydreaming counterbalance the girls' many virtuous traits. Secondary characters are interesting too. The swift-moving plot doesn't allow much time to get to know them, but we see that they are more than just cardboard cutouts, each having their own lives and motivations. The hardships the girls face, from the discomforts of heat and hunger, to working with manure all day, to plague and the danger of physical violence, are all real and grim enough without being gratuitously horrifying.
I was grateful for the author's note that this is not meant to truly show India or the Mughal empire, but only a similar imaginary country reminiscent of a certain place and time. I would not have known the difference. I would have liked a drawing or two of the costumes of the Believers and the indigenous people, as I had a hard time picturing the outfits just from the text descriptions.
In response to the three-star review: "the story is somewhat standard in the story concepts it uses. There are some slaves, a lot of running, and haughty nobles." Good stories tend to be built on one of a few common frameworks, because they work well. The coming-of-age journey story, in which the main character grows wiser and stronger as he travels, is classic. This is not a drawback. Also, this book includes servants, but I don't recall them being described as slaves specifically, and the haughty nobles are there to flesh out the story; at least one of them turns out to be not so haughty.
On a tangent: if you enjoyed this book, you might also like The Secrets of Jin-shei. It has more of a fantastical element and is darker, definitely an adult book rather than young adult.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting but not fantastic, Nov 30 2010
By Sniffly Kitty - Published on Amazon.com
Ce commentaire est de: Toads and Diamonds (Hardcover)
The sister who speaks toads also speaks snakes, and the author makes this into a good thing. Granted, making this into a good thing is not an easy task, and Tomlinson has a pretty good crack at it although the result still seems contrived.
Both sisters go on a journey, and their stories are intertwined. The transitions between the stories are pretty well done. Other than the twist of the fairy tale, the story is somewhat standard in the story concepts it uses. There are some slaves, a lot of running, and haughty nobles.
This was not a terrible novel but it was also not a fantastic one.
4 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Splendid Retelling!, April 7 2010
By Diamonds And Toads - Published on Amazon.com
Ce commentaire est de: Toads and Diamonds (Hardcover)
"Toads and Diamonds" is a brilliant, but sadly-neglected fairy tale. To my great joy and entertainment,, Tomlinson's book is an enchantingly rich retelling, seething with the loveliness of India, the enchantments of a goddess, and, best of all, real friendship. It's a delight to see this old story of step-family rivalry recast as a story of sisterly solidarity. Best of all, the story thoroughly examines the notion of the trickiness of magical "gifts" and "curses." I would encourage adult fairy tale lovers to check this out!
|
|
|