8 of 8 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Alleyn just gets Better!, July 1 2007
By Erin Bulman - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: A Treasury Of Regrets : A Mystery (Hardcover)
Anticipating the second book of a series for me is like riding a
roller-coaster between high hopes and lows of remembered
disappointments. Happily, Alleyn's second historical mystery
featuring Aristide Ravel fulfills the former - it's a terrific book,
easily as good as GAME OF PATIENCE, maybe even better.
Pace, voice, dialogue, narrative are all beautifully done.
The fact is, I am a big fan of police procedurals, with
a pretty sceptical attitude toward historical mysteries. Why? Too
often, an author loses the main plot/story in an attempt to
recreate the setting of another time. On and on they go about the
details of an unpaved street, the people on the street, the quaint
habits, the colorful dress, the inconveniences... until the reader
can't remember why we are on the street in the first place. Alleyn's
talent is that she recreates the time IN the characters of her story,
not in describing their setting in excruciating detail. It is in
their views and reactions to events that the reader gains a
vivid insight into, in this case, the period in France shortly after
the French Revolution. The Place de la Concorde comes alive
through Aristide's reaction to the death of a dear friend on the
guillotine. There's another great example in the first scene where
we learn that Aristide is either an agent of the police, a police spy
or an informer... or maybe just a friend of the commissaire, through
the eyes of people of that time. (And, it recaps vital info about the
previous book without giving any of that story away. That's good
writing.)
Roughly, the story begins with the death of the head of a seemingly
well-off family, and the accusation and arrest of a simple servant
girl who is accused not only of the murder but of attempting to
poison the whole family (despite the complete lack of motive).
Alleyn weaves a twisty, fascinating narrative filled with lots of
secrets, more deaths in the family, and great scenes as Aristide
searches for the truth. I was often surprised, often guessed wrong,
and loved the terrific ending. All in all, a real winner.
Very Highly Recommended.