2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars
Diets don't work for children, May 30 2002
This review is from: Trim Kids(Tm): The Proven 12-Week Plan That Has Helped Thousands of Children Achieve a Healthier Weight (Hardcover)
This book is really a diet in sheep's clothing. And
as a registered dietitian, I know that diets don't
work for children any better than they do for adults.
While the book does offer suggestions for exercise and
activity, its calorie recommendations (as low as 1,200
calories for girls 15-18 years old) may be too
restrictive. Also, expecting parents to follow weekly
meal plans is unrealistic and doesn't allow families
to find solutions that fit individual family patterns
and eating preferences. I especially disagree with
their recommendation to limit snacks. The book says
that snacks should be eaten only when the child
experiences "true hunger," which the authors say
occurs only after 2 to 4 hours of not eating. The
suggestion to give your child a big glass of water and
send them out to play if you deem them not truly
hungry seems a bit harsh. While children shouldn't eat
snacks simply because they're bored or see an ad for
food on the television, they also shouldn't be forced
to wait until they are starving before they are
allowed to eat a healthy snack. Going too long
between eating and becoming overly hungry is a set-up
for overeating at meals. Finally, the book expects
too much change too fast. Changes should be made
gradually. Expecting results in 12 weeks can be a set
up for failure, thereby further wounding the
self-esteem of a vulnerable overweight child and
creating frustration for parents.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No