9 of 9 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
The ultimate non-album compilation, Vol. 1, Jun 9 2008
By J. L. "NRN" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: V1 Extra (Audio CD)
EXTRA Vol. 1 is truly the definitive KMFDM collection. It spans all non-abum records of the 1986-1992 (up to Money) era which means En Esch (the guy, not the track), Split, long lost recordings, first-time CD masters for some songs, and all the original artwork for all singles. The WDYKD and DBYT! mixes featured here are even better than the album ones. All Split versions are also here (The Apart version being my personal favorite), along with a lengthier More & Faster and great Rip The System, Go to Hell, etc. mixes.
Disc 2 may sound a little repetitive with this "Money/Bargeld/Money/Bargeld..." thing, but not that much, specially considering that the original Money single was organized that way, and the different versions are really worthy the time you put on them, so this is not a real drawback. The sound quality is, for any practical purpose, the same as the KMFDM classics collection released in 2006-2007, so it fits perfectly with those records.
If you are an Ultra-Heavy Beat fan, this is a must have, unless, of course, you are rather into 24/7 (I'd be but I don't have a vinyl player anymore and I'm not buying those records just to frame them :)
Highly recommended. I'm looking forward to Volumes 2 and 3.
5.0 out of 5 stars
A lot of great music in one CD box!, Jan 14 2011
By Stuart Young - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: V1 Extra (Audio CD)
IMO, Extra Vol. 1 is almost a complete collection of early KMFDM songs which got a lot of airplay in clubs, on alternative radio, etc., plus remixed versions. It's a 2-CD set. The last several songs on the second CD does get a bit monotonous, though, with its alternating tracks of various versions of "Money" and "Bargeld." If it matters to you, you might want to set your player on "random shuffle" while playing the second CD. Otherwise, highly recommended!
4.0 out of 5 stars
Komplete Your Kollection!, Sep 3 2009
By codexwyrm "Tony" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: V1 Extra (Audio CD)
In an age where industrial music has become little more than a collection of solitary basement dwellers with an access virus and angst, this collection comes as a breath of fresh air. There's very little on here that represents the best that KMFDM has to offer, but interestingly, i find i like the material much more than when it heard it 15 years ago. The homogeny in the current industrial environment make the eclectic sounds they use in this old stuff sound relevant.
There is a fair amount you may have heard twenty years ago, and the remastering makes that part of it sound crisp. The rest that you probably haven't heard make the collection worthwhile. There is plenty of unreleased material, vinyl-onlys, and b-sides to keep a fanboy like myself entertained.