6 of 6 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting short stories but they were very inconsistent with D's character, Aug 27 2008
By Karissa Eckert "Devourer of all books fantasy" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Vampire Hunter D Volume 10: Dark Nocturne (Paperback)
This is the 10th novel in the Vampire Hunter D series. This novel is different from previous novels in that it is actually a collection of three novellas. I didn't realize this when I purchased the book. It was interesting to read short stories about D; I think this material lends itself to a short story type format.
The above being said this was probably the worst installment in the Vampire Hunter D series yet. The first story (after which the book is named) is just off. D had a flippant attitude that is very unlike his normal stoic demeanor. In fact the character of D didn't seem to be like D at all; for a second I thought Zorro had stepped in to take D's place. All of the characters in this story were a bit off; the whole story was out of context and out of place.
The remaining two stories were more in keeping with D's character; although D seemed to be a little more chatty than normal in the second story too. I was a bit disappointed overall because part of the reason I enjoy these books is the slow and reluctant unfolding of D's character. These stories undermined that by changing D's character willy-nilly and confusing me about who I was reading about.
The book was okay. The first story awful, the second two somewhat interesting. I am excited for the next book because that is supposed to go back to the original Hunter D format.
karissabooks.blogspot.com
4.0 out of 5 stars
Three short stories..., Feb 2 2009
By Michael Valdivielso - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Vampire Hunter D Volume 10: Dark Nocturne (Paperback)
Three short stories which are OK but in which D does seem to step out of character every once and a while. Stepping out of character, for any character, can mess up a story easily.
Still good, but not great. Try to get it used or out of the library.
3.0 out of 5 stars
A collection of short stories. Not as good as full length ones., April 26 2008
By Adrian - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Vampire Hunter D Volume 10: Dark Nocturne (Paperback)
I like the Vampire Hunter D series of books. Not too keen on this one though. It's a collection of three short stories. While the scenarios are in keeping with the world D lives in (full of supernatural monsters in the year 12090AD), D seems to be written out of character, as he talks too much. In all his other proper books, he is a person of few words and rarely startled.
In hindsight, I would skipped this book and waited for the next one, which I think will be a doozy.