is a CD version of "Folk Song and Minstrelsy" which is fondly remembered by legions of folk fans who owned the LP's. That one is a powerhouse of folk styles, with many tracks by Odetta and Cisco Houston, two of the very best "folk revival artists" along with many good selections by other label-mates. The package under consideration here goes beyond the "folk" category, and even some of the folk tracks best do not represent the best work of the performers. I was a folk fan from '58 on, and a Vanguard fan from that time through the '70's. On Disc One I like almost all the 22 tracks, although the ones by Count Basie, Jimmy Rushing, and The Weavers do not represent their strongest work on the label. On Disc Two, I like less than half the 22 selections. The offerings here by Pete Seeger, Judy Roderick, John Hammond, Greenbriar Boys, Doc Watson, Tom Paxton and Joan Baez are not the strongest possible choices for those artists. Disc Three has a blues emphasis, but I don't like the blues enough to want 20 tracks, many by artists with lesser careers. And on Disc Four we have some good jazz, with several folk and pop tracks thrown in for filler.
This set was a gift, and I am glad to hear it once, and I will give Disc One and the first half of Disc Two repeat play. But the rest of the set is just not memorable. I am fortunate enough to own homemade CD transfers of "Folk Song and Minstrelsy" and that set gets played at least four times a year in my car. Why Vanguard cannot get it out on CD, and heavily advertised, I do not understand. I personally have heard from a dozen people over the years who remember it from childhood or teen years and desperately want to own playable copies now, later in their lives, so they can introduce some of the artists and songs to children and grandkids. Somebody at Vanguard needs to look into this.