15 of 17 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
A very satisfying read, May 30 2008
By Gale Mead - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Very Hard Choices (Hardcover)
Very Hard Choices revisits the characters introduced in Very Bad Deaths, and again presents them with difficult, painful, life-threatening circumstances that force them to consider both the ethics and the morality of the choices they face. To say much more might upset certain surprising turns in the storyline, but suffice it to say that the first reviewer of this book got it wrong. The story does not suggest the US is in danger of being turned into a "religious dictatorship," nor is the story's antagonist working towards that goal. The threat, rather, is framed as a takeover by a very small cabal of extremely wealthy, powerful, and conscience-less autocrats. Sounds more like real life than science fiction to me! If you're an ardent right-winger, you probably won't like some of this book's premises. Everyone else is in for an enjoyable, and thought-provoking ride.
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars
Very Disappointing Novel, Jun 7 2009
By C. Baker "cbaker" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Very Hard Choices (Hardcover)
I love Spider Robinson. Anyone who admires the Grand Master Robert A. Heinlein as much as I do is a saint my book. Thus it pains to me to say that this novel is a disaster.
Very Hard Choices is a sequel to the pretty good novel Very Bad Deaths. There we meet Russell Walker, the aging hippie, who sets out to help his old college roommate Zudie, who happens to be a telepath, chase down a nasty killer. He has the help of Constable Nika Mandic, the rather hot female cop. All turns out, if not completely well, well enough.
Here, Nika shows up at Russell's doorstep with some news, while Russell is at home visiting with his estranged son Jesse. It turns out the CIA is still hunting for Zudie for purposes unknown, but probably not very good ones, or so everyone surmises. This sets off a chain of events where Nika, Russell, and Jesse try to protect Zudie (short for Zandor Zudenigo) from the CIA agent chasing him. Everything culminates to a final confrontation in the end, but to avoid spoilers I'll stop here with the plot summary.
Unfortunately this novel is more a political or philosophical polemic through the thoughts of Russell Walker than it is a real novel. Yes, a story is embedded here, but the story itself could have been told in a short novella. Instead the prose drags on and on with chase scenes and the musings of Russell, but not in a very smooth or compelling way. I'm not sure if Russell is supposed to be a caricature of Spider Robinson or not, but it sure seems like it. But overall the characters seem more quirky than real, which maybe is the point. But the novel is just not that entertaining.
10 of 12 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Now this is serious stuff...., Jun 23 2008
By MixMeister - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Very Hard Choices (Hardcover)
The sequel to Very Bad Deaths was something I had been waiting for with some trepidation: what story was there left to tell? The thrilling yet non-graphic horror that the former book had titillated me with should have warned me.
Although I had been prepared for some more of that insightful prose in that trademark way that Spider writes in, I did not expect that he would take the tale of the suffering telepath Zudie more than one step further. Everyone thinks that being a telepath may be a mild nuisance if you cannot turn the talent off at will. But this tale makes you feel what he feels and makes you understand why he had to retreat into obscurity... damn.. 't is difficult to not spoil the fun for would-be readers. Let me just wrap this up by stating "yes, he's done it again, he keeps evolving, and the stories keep getting more interesting and insightful each step of the way".
See if you can read the introductory chapters over there at the Baen Books website and then keep away from this one... even if you have not read the first book.