Waltz With Bashir

 

 

Create your own review

There isn't much to say about this film that can justify its power. It's beyond your typical animated fare and has to be seen. Incredible direction and style combined with great story-telling. Rented it but had to buy it since I'll definitely return to this one. Not for children.

This is an excellent film that takes the medium of the graphic novel to the screen as an innovative approach to dealing with the trauma of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. It's not the first use of animation as a kind of metaphor for the way personal experiences of trauma initially too difficult to deal with are often skewed or buffered in our memory for future processing, or simply buried there indefinitely. However, in a post-9/11 global ethical environment in which the whole world has for so long now seemed almost like a bad comic book rendering of reality, this film gets as close to the effects and individual experiences of war and violence than the most "live" images from mainstream media sources. Highly recommended.

The animation in this film is a work of art -- a kind of 21st-century expressionism -- especially considering that no rotoscoping was used to produce it. But this is a must-see documentary even apart from its unique visual qualities.

Ari Folman began work on this film by sending out a request for veterans of the Israeli occupation of Lebanon to give their personal accounts of what happened (20 years after the fact). He got 300 responses, and selecting from these, recorded several interviews in the studio. The stories (and the men telling them) were then storyboarded, and the storyboards turned into animations (with the narration dubbed in English for the American release). If there is one quality that all these stories have in common, it's the horrifying absurdity of it all. Both factual events and nightmares are depicted here, and it's often difficult to tell the difference. As Folman remarks in one of the extras on the DVD, many films have been made with the message that war is hell, but in most of them the central characters manage to display some heroic qualities. That is emphatically not the case here; there is no trace of heroism, glory or even admirable qualities in these true stories of terrified youth blundering their way through impossible situations.

However, despite the variety of story sources, the film develops a compelling momentum. The story is held together by the thread of one man's efforts to recover his lost memories of that time, and to deal with those memories as the evidence accumulates for what really happened. It builds up steadily to a climax in the massacre of refugee Palestinians by the Christian Falangists, in revenge for their murdered leader Bashir -- while the Israeli soldiers (or rather their officers) look on and allow it to happen. In the end it's the filmmaker's determination to face the truth about this massacre that brings out the positive side of human nature.

This film does bear comparison with Persepolis, another animated film based on autobiographical sources. Both are visually stunning; Persepolis is perhaps more entertaining, but Waltz with Bashir is more rivetting, and in the end has a more powerful impact. See Persepolis to understand Iranians, and women everywhere; see this film to understand Israelis, and young men everywhere who get caught up in war, and what it does to them. And to understand the nature of memory -- which is the real "star" in this amazing film.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 5 customer reviews on Amazon.ca

 

1.0 out of 5 stars very disapointed
very tiresome, the original language and sound dominated the whole movie and the graphic was very poor.Icould not watch it to the end

Published 8 months ago by daisy

5.0 out of 5 stars A powerful movie!
A powerful movie! If "Waltz with Bashir" does not cause you to question humanities darkside nothing will. It will leave you asking "why?"

Published on Mar 26 2010 by DCG

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 5 customer reviews on Amazon.ca

Search Listmania!