Most helpful customer reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
Quick and Simple Advice for Christians Who Suffer, July 7 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: 100 Ways to Overcome Depression (Paperback)
Frank Minirth is a genuinely caring doctor who offers advice from his many years experience as a psychiatrist at Minirth-Meier Clinics. This book is a concise and handy resource for anyone struggling with depression and/or anxiety.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
THIS BOOK HELPED ME SO MUCH!!, Dec 24 2002
This review is from: 100 Ways to Overcome Depression (Paperback)
I REALIZE THAT NO BOOK IS A MIRACLE WORKER FOR THE CURE OF DEPRESSION. I WAS GOING THROUGH A HORRIBLE TIME WITH DEPRESSION. I FELT LIKE I WAS IN A PIT. THIS LITTLE BOOKED HELPED ME SO MUCH. THE REASON IT DID WAS BECAUSE IT WAS FULL OF GOD'S WORD, ALONG WITH GOOD SOUND ADVICE. I WOULD READ THE LITTLE BOOK OVER AND OVER AGAIN. I ALSO READ MY BIBLE. I EVEN SLEPT WITH MY BIBLE. LOTS OF THE ADVICE IN THE LITTLE BOOK HELPED ME TO HAVE HOPE DURING MY DEPRESSION. I ENJOYED THIS BOOK VERY MUCH. NOTHING IS A QUICK FIX. BUT THIS LITTLE BOOK WAS A BIG PART OF MY RECOVERY. THE REASON I CAME ON THIS SITE WAS TO SEE IF I COULD ORDER ONE FOR A FRIEND. THANK SO MUCH AND GOD BLESS YOUR MINISTRY, ELAINE
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
73 of 79 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars
Authors feel that depression is a spiritual problem only, Feb 2 1999
By A Customer - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: 100 Ways to Overcome Depression (Paperback)
I am Christian, and I also have been diagnosed with depression. When I received this book, I opened it expecting anecdotes and little things to do in my daily living to help me get through my depression. However, the book focuses entirely on Christianity. Phrases such as "The person who is depressed should ask himself what he is doing to make himself depressed. He may discover that he is living a lifestyle that is clearly against God." For those to which this statement applies, the book could be very helpful. The authors believe that depression is some sort of mindset that can be easily overcome, not a real disease that millions deal with daily. If you want tangible ways to overcome depression, beyond prayer and an active relationship with God, then look elsewhere.
44 of 62 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars
Depression, Mind Based, Not Bible Based, April 2 2000
By "socrates11" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: 100 Ways to Overcome Depression (Paperback)
I am very disturbed that the author is even allowed to publish his ideas concerning depression. I am a 57 year old man, who just recently after 9 years of "chemical" inbalance deep depression, evolved into complete freedom from depression. It was the right "chemical" medicine, from a great doctor, which saved my mental life. I would still be in a state of horrible depression, if i was waiting for Prayer as a cure. The author needs to realize that there are two kinds of depression:(1) "chemical" inbalance,(2)mild, or no "chemical" inbalance. The first one is finally treated only by correct "chemical" medication, which brings you out of the depression itself. It is organic in nature, like an infection of the body, which can be healed by a wonder drug. You take aspirin to help stop pain by a "chemical" action in your body; you could pray all day and a tooth ache will not stop hurting. Likewise, "chemical" inbalance depression of the brain will be erased only by "chemical" means: proper medicine given by a doctor who deals with "chemical" inbalance disease. Mild depression, on the other hand, is treated by talking out your problem. A certain idea in your head is bothering you; after talking about it( whether death of a friend, husband, or loss of a job), a person over a period of time comes out of depression. It is not "chemical" in nature. It may be emotional,etc.; however, it can be resolved by talking it "out" loud, so to speak, with any person who will just listen very carefully to you. After a period of time, the person in "mild" depression will get over it, or will no longer be in depression. The idea that a "christian" life style, as suggested by the author, can treat severe, "chemical" inbalance depression-- is just plain foolishness. It is very dangerous; and, i am sure that most people will take it with a "grain" of salt--so to speak. The author should concern himself with religion, and get out of the "mental" health field. He presents solutions which are bible based; the correct solutions, which most educated people would likely agree with, are mind based.
30 of 42 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars
Unbelievably misguiding, Nov 8 2000
By A Customer - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: 100 Ways to Overcome Depression (Paperback)
The notion that depression is not real and rather a state of mind is frustratingly misguiding and the reason that scores of people commit suicide around the world every day. Depression is a crippling disease that requires treatment and therapy just like any other and anybody who has ever fought it knows this. What this book screamed to me as someone who is vulnerable to mild depression, is that people allow themselves to be depressed; That depression is an attitude, perhaps one I can wake up tomorrow and throw out the window. But the truth is, it is not. It is not something we imagine nor is it something we can forget. In fact, sometimes, we don't even have a clue what is causing it in our lives so how can we simply "pray for it to end." I'm somebody who talks to God and prays for help with a lot of the challenges that come across my life, but even I know that depression is not something, which will simply go away with prayer. A person needs friends, support, therapy and sometimes a prescription to fight depression.
|
|
|