What's Wrong with Our Schools: and How We Can Fix Them [Hardcover]

 

 

Create your own review

First a caution. Although there is no financial involvement, I did provide advice during the writing of this book. However, I would not have done so had I not been very impressed by the initial version.

This is indeed a common sense guide to current elementary and secondary education in North America. It calmly - there is no hyperbole - addresses current issues and illustrates the right and wrong way to go, all consistent with the research where applicable - there are many major issues with which research cannot deal. The book is particularly valuable for parents, many of whom will agree with the authors' conclusions, but fear to raise them with educators. The book will also be useful for those teachers who are not enamored with Deweyan progressivism and the continual sequence of reforms whose main function is to lower educational standards.

I was shocked to hear in the news what is going on in our schools and didn't want to believe it was happening in my daughters. But then I found out that they had a no fail policy and a no mark deduction policy for late/missing assignments. Then they wanted to remove percent grades from reports cards in favour of nebulous assessments. I went to the PTA meeting armed with this book and made it clear that I was going to fight for a good education for my daughter.

This book is full of good ideas and arguments against the dumbing down of our educational system and has clear, concise language that cuts through the edu-babble that confuses parents and makes no sense (it turns out it really doesn't make sense!). This is definately worth your while if you are concerned about your child's education and future.

Although touted as heralds for the next wave of school policy reform, Michael Zwaagstra and his co-authors present a model for education that is remarkably traditional and conservative. This book appeals to popular opinion and common sense to the exclusion of solid research and academic study. Their focus on standards and academic rigor attest to the conservative swing of the education pendulum occuring right now. This book of opportunity takes the message of de-formative reform to the public.

My criticisms are many.

1. "Case Studies" are fake, misleading, and offensive. At the beginning of each chapter, the authors present a hypothetical situation to illustrate their point. Here, they lean the ridiculous suggestions and blatant hyperbole to sway the emotions, rather than the minds, of their readers. They frequently paint teachers, administrators, and policy-makers as incompetent and lazy, implying that teachers are not motivated by the best-interests of their students. When the situation doesn't pack enough punch, the authors rely on cheap tactics to make their reader side with them. For example, when talking about Student-Led Conferences, the authors make sure that we are aware that the mother is uncomfortable in the small chair because her skirt is too short, subtlely implying that the conference is the cause of the mother's loss of innocence (and unnecessarily invoking the sexual modesty of their largely conservative readers). In the same story, the authors make sure that we know that the teacher was a bit late. If the argument is valid, you should not rely on such low-grade tricks to convince your audience.

2. The policies presented are ridiculous. With chapter titles like "Direct instruction is good teaching" and "classrooms should be teacher-centred" it's a wonder that the authors have ever even inhabited a faculty of education. There are reams and reams of research that deny the efficacy of their type of classroom, but the authors tend to ignore research that does not fit their ends.

3. Poorly researched and quotes taken out of context. I'm sure many of the researchers and theorists quoted in the book would be offended by the spirit in which their words are presented. Quotations are so cut-up and plastered around the page, there is no way that the original thought was anywhere close to what is presented in the book. At one point, the authors quote page numbers from the same article in reverse order (first page 10, then 9...) in the same paragraph!

4. The writing in unimaginative, childish, and condescending. I could tell as soon as I started thumbing through the book that I was really looking at a series of undergraduate papers. The parallel organization of each chapter (with sub-headings, in case I couldn't understand!) was boring and took any thrill out of reading. You don't need to tell me that a passage is an introduction. I know that based on the fact that it is introducing the chapter. Also, if you like rhetorical questions, you'll be in for a treat. They use them extensively. A rhetorical device is only effective for the first 20 iterations. After that, it gets irritating.

5. The appeal to common-sense. A clever (and "grass-roots") way of avoiding key academic questions. They hide behind "common-sense" to avoid clarifying their opinions or presenting legitimate supporting research. In fact, the majority of these appeals rely on the fact that the readers will apply their own conceptions of public education (based on their personal experience) onto the modern system. I constantly hear the phrase "In my day..." as I read. This is also how they manipulate their readers into believing them. If it's common-sense then only idiots wouldn't believe us, right?

Overall I found this book a superb waste of time for the serious educator. As an exercise in contrarian rhetoric, it served its purpose in re-affirming my own beliefs about school, but to actually consider the recommendations presented in this book would be misguided and harmful. If you want to go back to schools as they were, ignoring the research and throwing out everything we know about good teaching, you can take this book's message to heart. Otherwise, you're better off reading something with a bit more substance and conducted by reputable scholars.

After reading it, I couldn't live with myself knowing that it had 5 stars on Amazon.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 3 customer reviews...

 

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

Search Listmania!