7 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Can I get those 6 hours of my life back?, Oct 13 2010
By Some Girl "rb" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Wicked Duke Takes a Wife (Mass Market Paperback)
This book was just plain bad. I'm someone who finishes a book, no matter how terrible I'm finding it. This book made me sorely wish that wasn't the case.
The plot was all but non-existent with very poorly manufactured drama, little to no sexual tension, and characters that I felt no connection to whatsoever. I didn't get any sense of a growing attraction--let alone a relationship--between the main characters. I don't mind my romances with a lust/love at first sight motif, but I didn't get that from this story either. It seemed like there wasn't really a story at all - just an idea that got a thumbs up from the publisher and then got dragged out for 300 or so pages by the author.
And the tie-in to "Frankenstein"? Unnecessary and nonsensical. I also didn't understand Griffin being described as "wicked" or "dark". Am I supposed to buy that he's comparable to Frankenstein's monster because he looks mean when people first meet him? Or because he wasn't married yet (though he's constantly described as a "young duke")? All I surmised was that the author loves "Frankenstein" and made up a way to shove it into her "book."
I could go on about how much I didn't like this book (what was with the weird line somewhere near the end that Griffin thought Harriet blamed him for her father's death when there wasn't anything before that would make us think he was connected to that at all-and then the idea was never considered again after it crosses the "hero's" mind... it bothered me that I didn't know either character's age... I assume Edlyn will get her own book at some point but she was just a weird plot device in this one... my agreement with another reviewer that it seemed absurd that the main characters didn't even have a conversation about the differences in their stations...), but I think my point comes across and I don't want to sink to the level of vitriol-spewing.
I guess I'll just close with the point that I really am glad to see the positive reviews for this book--there's something out there for everyone. But I won't be buying any more Jillian Hunter books - just not my cup of tea.
6 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Have to agree it is a bit weak..., Nov 9 2009
By mks "Avid reader" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Wicked Duke Takes a Wife (Mass Market Paperback)
I have to agree with Old Latin Teacher's review: this is an easy read, but a disappointing one. Most disappointing was the total improbability of this particular story - a duke falling in LOVE with the low-born heroine, his family being pleased with the match (despite public scorn for the pair), and there being celebration and acceptance for this socially mismatched pair at the end with no acknowledgement of the earlier ostracism that was threatened. Lust between them? Sure - that would fit with the times and with the amount of time this story gave the pair to interact. But love and marriage? Not on your life. This romance forces the storybook ending without any believability.
This was also a highly formulaic effort - there were few, if any, surprises or twists to keep it interesting. It was lacking in rich story telling. It seemed to rush from plot device to plot device so quickly that you could not grow to appreciate the story or the characters.
Overall, this particular book was a disappointment to me. I kept at it hoping it would improve, but when I was done, I felt I had wasted my time. If you go into to it with relatively low expectations and for a quick read, it is passable, but overall, there are many better books out there.
5 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The Wicked Duke Takes A Wife, Nov 22 2009
By L. S. Lemon "keeper of books" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Wicked Duke Takes a Wife (Mass Market Paperback)
I ordered this book because of the author and it was part of the Bocastle series. I had hoped that it was book about another of Gabriel's brothers so was a little disappointed that it about another branch of the family. I did like the book but I found it a little light on the usual character development and I felt that the ending was a little sloppy and rushed