Most helpful customer reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Underrated, Excellent, Unexpectedly Compassionate Portrayal, April 9 2001
Oliver Stone's "Nixon" is quite simply a great American film, one that has been shamefully overlooked in comparison with the seriously flawed "JFK." Stone obviously took notice of the criticisms of that earlier film, and while some of his conspiracy-mania appears in "Nixon", overall the later film is a much more balanced and human effort. Stone can direct like a lunatic (has anybody but the seriously disturbed sat through "Natural Born Killers" more than once?) but he is an undeniably intelligent and talented filmmaker who can rise to the occasion when challenged. And he was obviously challenged by the task of coming to terms with Richard Nixon, the dominant political figure of his youth. Stone dedicated the movie to his late father, and it is obviously an attempt by a son to understand patriarchal authority--and its abuses. Stone's aggressive style is much on display here, but it helps draw you into the drama, rather than distracting as it has in other films. Ther's some truly inspired casting, from David Hyde Pierce as John Dean to James Woods and J.T. Walsh as Haldeman and Ehrlichman, to the splendid Joan Allen as Pat Nixon. But the centerpiece is Anthony Hopkins as Nixon who gives another remarkable performance in his patented manner of "clenched flamboyance" (as one critic described his acting.) He makes you feel every hurt, every slight that the man ever felt, as well as letting us see the undeniable brilliance as well as the pathetic flaws. By the time the Mormon Tabernacle Choir sings "Shanendoah" over footage of Nixon's funeral and the closing credits (a masterful, unironic touch) you may find yourself genuinely grieving over the wasted genius. One of the best political films ever made, one whose reputation should grow over the coming years.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
fascinating character study on blu-ray, Aug 5 2010
Anthony Hopkins gives a stunning and complex portrayal of Nixon, while leading a well-cast ensemble of talent (Paul Sorvino, Joan Allen, James Woods etc.). Though not a stickler for historical accuracy, Oliver Stone's fascinating epic character study is technically well made, especially this extended director's cut, and again utilizes the director's known flashback and multi-format editing style. The election year blu-ray edition has a second disc of bonus features, which includes a lot of Oliver Stone - deleted scenes, with director intros, Charlie Rose interview, trailer, and a new documentary, Beyond Nixon (which contains many insider reactions to the film). Additionally, there are two director commentaries - one focused on cast, crew and filmmaking, and the other focused on political history.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Stone's Attempt at "Citizen Kane", July 3 2009
This review is from: Nixon (Widescreen Collector's Edition) (DVD)
It's impossible to watch "Nixon" without seeing the parallels with Welles' masterpiece. The fragmented narrative, the self-reflexive camera techniques, the newsreel, the portrait of a power-mad love-hungry icon are all suggestive. There's more, too, and some academic will doubtless write a paper if it hasn't been written already. Judged against "Kane" of course "Nixon" falls short. But once the resonances start penetrating, this film becomes a sequel to that earlier portrait of power. The American Character--if such a thing exists--is really at the heart of this film. Forget whether or not you hate the real Nixon and revel in Hopkins' portrayal of the cinematic one.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|