4.0 out of 5 stars
China's future through three people, Mar 27 2004
I just came back from a trip to China and was interested in learning more about the country but wasn't too interested in heavy academic writing. This book was good on both counts.
The author uses the stories of three people to explain the problems facing China. His point is that China is developing quickly economically but its poliitcal system is stuck in the past. I thought this was a pretty good analysis of China and it was brought home by the three people's stories. My favorite was about a young guy trying to save the historic center of Bejiing. I had seen on my trip how the old city was being torn down and had assumed that there wasn't much opposition to this. But I was surprised to read about how thousands of people have tried to sue the government to stop the city's destruction. I was also impressed by the scope of the writer's knowledge. Even though he focuss just on three people, he really covers a lot of ground and you end up learning a lot about Chinese history and culture.
If there's a reason I didn't give this five stars, it's that the book might be too pessimistic. The author says he isn't trying to predict China future but the picture he gives is of a society that's going to have inevitable conflicts with the government. When I was in China, people told me how their country had reformed its economy gradually. I wonder if this couldn't work for politics as well? Maybe the author underestimates this?
Overall, however, this is a very nice book, well-written and full of interesting facts and description of famous and remote parts of the country. I could recommend it to anyone planning a trip there or just interested in this fascinating country.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Ordinary People, Extraordinary Courage, May 10 2004
WILD GRASS contains three stories (they can't be termed novellas because they are true, although they are novella length) that show, quite poignantly, how change has, and has not, affected ordinary people in modern China.
China today is the China created by Deng Xiaoping, not Chairman Mao, or at least it should be. Things, however, haven't changed as much as one might think. WILD GRASS shows us that China's "common man" is still struggling to claim the freedom, prosperity and happiness promised to him under the regime of Deng Xiaoping.
All of the three stories in WILD GRASS center around ordinary people who exhibit extraordinary courage. The first is Ma Wenlin, a former Red Guard and former teacher who defies his village officials regarding illegal taxes levied on him and the other village peasants. In fact, he files a class action lawsuit on everyone's behalf. The village officials refuse to hear his case so he takes his cause to Beijing where the unbelievable happens.
The second story actually takes place in Beijing, itself, as residents of that city's old town fight to keep their lovely and historic homes from being replaced by modern, gleaming skyscrapers that will accommodate the crowds of people that will arrive for the coming Olympics. Sometimes, where we live is just as important as how we live.
The third story revolves around the rise of Falun Gong and Chen Zixiu, a mother and grandmother who embraces it. Unfortunately, Chen Zixiu isn't content to simply embrace the serenity and compassion of Falun Gong, she's determined to correct the Beijing officials misrepresentations of the movement as well. Chen Zixiu suffers the worst fate of any of the book's protagonists.
WILD GRASS is an extremely well written book but one that is very sad and quite depressing. Many westerners, like me, think life in modern China is changing, albeit slowly, but, in WILD GRASS we learn that it's not changing as quickly as we might have thought it was and that all change is not for the good.
WILD GRASS is definitely not a pessimistic book, however. While the author doesn't seem to place much hope in China's political leaders he does seem to have great faith in her ordinary, everyday people and this is what he showcases. WILD GRASS, while telling us a lot about the politics of modern China, is definitely not a political book. It is an extraordinarily human one.
The true stories in WILD GRASS ultimately raise more questions about modern China than they answer, but this is, I think, how it should be. I liked this book because it focused more on people than on politics. I think WILD GRASS is a very important book and I wouldn't hesitate to recommend it to anyone. It's beautifully written and it should be required reading for anyone interested in modern China.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
China at the grassroots, April 14 2004
This book uses three people to tell the story of today's China. Through a lawyer, a student and a small-town worker we get inside the problems in China's cities, towns and villages. The author tells the three individuals' tales like short stories but adds in enough background and other material so you end up understanding a lot about contemporary China as well.
The book was a real quick-read--I read through it in no time at all because I wanted to find out what happened to the three people. Would they succeed in challenging the government? Would they be defeated?
The author should also be commended for taking some personal risks in telling these stories. They seem to have involved a lot of travel to remote parts of China.
All in all, I can strongly recommend this for anyone who enjoys literary non-fiction in general and the topic of China more specifically.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No