Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful
No Eisner but Still pretty goodMay 31 2010
- Published on Amazon.com
Volume 27 of the Spirit Archives presents a changed from previous volumes. Firtst off, it's published by Dark Horse Comics and not DC Comics like the previous volumes in the series. So why the change? Well this volume collects the issues originally presented in The Spirit: The New adventures #1 - 8, originally published by Kitchen Sink Press in 1997 - 1998. So I guess the reason is Dark Horse had the rights to the Kitchen Sink material, and with DC's blessing, published this volume to fit nicely in to the numbering of the DC volumes.
The other thing that makes this volume different is that creator Will Eisner steps aside and allows an all-star lineup of writers and artists to take a stab at his legendary character. The talent roster includes writers Alan Moore, Neil Gaiman, John Wagner, Kurt Busiek, Mark Shultz, John Ostrander, Joe R. Landsdale, and artists Dave Gibbons, Paul Pope, Tom Mandrake, Bo Hampton, Daniel Torres, And Paul Chadwick.
In fact the first three tales are courtesy of the famous Watchmen team of Moore and Gibbons but their tales are far from that cynical, yet groundbreaking work. Gibbons' art is far removed from his Watchmen style, and done to emulate the noirish 1940s style of Eisner. Their tale "The Most Important Meal" gives a take on the death of Denny Colt as seen through the eyes of the man who killed him.
These tales feature the Spirit's usual cast of characters including his famous femme fatales Sand Saref, Mink Stole and Villains like Dr. Cobra. The group does a surprisingly masterful job of capturing the, uhhh...spirit of the Spirit including Eisner's trademark sense of humor. Not all of the artists are able to frame their work in the Eisner style...he was essentially a film director working in panel art...but the art is uniformly outstanding throughout. I tend to think these Archive books, and not just the Spirit, but all of them from DC, Marvel, Dark Horse, etc., are a bit over-priced at $50. Still this is great work by a fantastic group of comic creators.
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful
The Spirit's New Adventures RocksDec 18 2010
- Published on Amazon.com
32 of comicdom's greatest writers and artists pay homage to Will Eisner's wonderful and mysterious detective, The Spirit" with all new adventures. Many fun stories in this great graphic work -- Alan Moore, Neil Gaiman, Moebius, and Mark Schultz are just some of the contributors. You must order this book now. You will not be disappointed.