Windwalker: Starlight & Shadows, Book 3 Mass Market Paperback – Apr 1 2004
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
No Kindle device required. Download one of the Free Kindle apps to start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, and computer.
To get the free app, enter your e-mail address or mobile phone number.
About the Author
Inside This Book(Learn More)
Top Customer Reviews
I love this character of hers, Liriel. The unusual drow with a taste for exploration and adventure. I like the fact that she's less diabolicly evil, more vitriolicly sarcastic with a soft heart for the lesser creatures. But Liriel seems to digress in this book.
At times during Windwalker Liriel seems to have forgotten what she's learn in her previous adventures. She forgets that she loves Fyodor (even though it scares her), that her killing people upsets Fyodor, that she really DOSEN'T love Lloth, and that another goddess has showed serious interest in recruting her. Meanwhile the maidens of the Promanade Temple seem to have forgotten the risks she took, the fighting she did for them, and the sacrifices she's made.
This book felt really rushed, 'jumpy' as someone else said. Too much story packed into too small a book equals somewhat shallow characters and a story that feels paper thin. Don't get me wrong it's not a bad read, just... I was hoping for so much more.
The second downfall for me was that I had not read book II in about a year. Leaving me lost when certain characters were re-introduced. Unlike R.A Salvatore who tends to go into a paragraph of re-introductions to help you along, Elaine leaves it up to you to figure it out. I used to think the 'flashback' "last we saw him..." type effect was a waste of pages, now I believe its a good addition to fill the years gap from book to book. Elaine could have used that method to keep me up-to-date, but she didn't. So I recommend re-reading the last book to make this one a little more interesting and easier to read.
Now, on to the good stuff. I was very happy to see the odd twists Elaine used for her wizard drow against her former godess Lolth. The symbolic battle between three gods over a single human was a neat addition to the book. Leaving you wondering "what happens next" with the god's struggle to get the favor of Liriel. Her battle with her former priestess adversary ended in a suprising result. Showing that the most intelligent drow can understand how easily they can fall prey to "vengence" -- the drows worse enemy (and usual cause for death).Read more ›
The story is intriging, with a constant sense of haste and frustration similar to the fifth Harry Potter book. The return of many characters, including a number of the 7 sisters, were expertly woven throughout. One new character, Sharlarra, an elven mage-thief, may in fact be poised for a series of her own. The ending to Windwalker is heartwrenching, but well written.
Windwalker is definitey the end the Starlight and Shadows series - there may be additional stories with Liriel in them, but they will be very different. I would recommend this book to any who have read the previous two, with the understanding that this well written book is darker in tone and different in its overall orientation and writing style.
The lighthearted, whimsical scripting, and elegant turns of phrase that made the first two books a joy to read are often absent, which harms the flow of the narrative early in the book. In their absence, the many changes of perspective make the pace seem forced. More seriously, the deft characterisations are now imperfectly conveyed.
In the prelude of the first book, in a handful of pages, Mrs. Cunningham managed to evoke the whole essence of the dark elven race, Gromph and Liriel in particular. She set a scene, then explored it through the deliciously calculating eyes of the evil old drow. But in Windwalker, scenes in the Underdark do not explore new territory, are too far from the action, and lack the immediacy that would have made them relevant. A single scene of the spying archmage in some interesting and relevant setting might have served better. The same holds for other "distant" perspectives. Some enemies could have appeared just as well spontaneously, in context with others. Meanwhile not enough is done to explain odd actions, like Azar or Sharlarra's obsessions with Liriel. A few subtle signs of restlessness or dissatisfaction in Sharlarra to Danilo's perceptive gaze when she first appears might have made a beginning. Mrs. Cunningham crafted complex new characters, but then suffered from a difficulty in getting them across.
But ultimately, the book isn't about any of them. Windwalker is the story of Liriel Baenre, and this is where it reigns supreme. In Windwalker, Mrs.Read more ›
Most recent customer reviews
I loved her other 2 books in the series... I use to read them every summer but I read this ... and a part of me cried inside ... I wish I had never read this honestly . Read morePublished 2 months ago by Ange
The Liriel who was not above killing, but did not enjoy it has been replaced by someone who kills first and asks questions later. Read morePublished on June 22 2004 by Jered Wenderoth
i don't care what other people have said! This is the best work of art i have yet to read in the Forgetten Realms! Elaine is my favorite author! Read morePublished on May 9 2004 by Jamie
I love reading about Drow, and so normally I am willing to cut any books about them a bit of slack. Unfortunately, this book was so bad that even I couldn't enjoy it. Read morePublished on April 23 2004 by Amazon Customer
My older cousin was the one who got me hooked on this book. I dont want to ruin it for anyone, so I wont say how it ends. Read morePublished on Jan. 30 2004
I liked the first two books a lot but this one was quite different. It was written a few years later I believe and included a whole slew of characters who's roles in the story made... Read morePublished on Jan. 28 2004 by 134523234
Elaine Cunningham's third Liriel Baenre novel, the final in the Starlight and Shadows trilogy, is decent enough, albeit not one of her best work. Read morePublished on Dec 29 2003 by Mario G. Estacio
After enjoying the first two books of this series, I was very excited about this one. But I was doomed to be disappointed. One of EC's strengths is her character development. Read morePublished on Oct. 21 2003
Tangled Webs was an amazing book. EC should have ended the story there. Nothing really happens in this book. Read morePublished on Oct. 6 2003 by Dex Win