6 of 6 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
A good but disappointing read, Aug 28 2011
Similar to the other reviewers, I had great expectations after reading The Name of the Wind. The first 500 pages of Wise Man's Fear are fabulous. Rothfuss manages to take us back to Kvothe's world effortlessly. Unfortunately, the next four hundred pages could have been condensed into a few chapters. He spends too much time on certain parts and the great book slowly becomes frustrating. The writing seems to be more contrived during these sections as well. Kvothe's sexual experiences could have been condensed into a chapter or two, but instead Rothfuss spends chapters and chapters discussing these escapades. If anything, it detracts the reader and makes us feel more distant from the character. In fact in one part, I thought I was reading a harliquin romance.
Rothfuss has been blessed with a wonderful imagination and a creative spirit. The book will take you away again to the fantasy world we were anxiously awaiting but don't expect it to be as good as the first. Rothfuss needed a wise and fearless editor and he would have had a sensational book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Memorable characters and polished writing, Mar 23 2011
For anyone who enjoyed "The Name of the Wind", I can cut straight to the point: "The Wise Man's Fear" is of the same high quality and continues the story of Kvothe to the level that you'd probably hoped for. Go get it!
For anyone who hasn't read the first book by Mr. Rothfuss, I recommend that you read it first. There are too many plot points that will be completely foreign to you in "The Wise Man's Fear" without prior knowledge of the basic storyline. Mr. Rothfuss does a good job attempting to make this story stand on its own but the characters (especially the secondary ones) would probably seem too hollow, or at least unmemorable. This story is about the characters!
In general what you'll find in a Rothfuss story is exceptionally polished and clean-flowing prose with a distinct amount of wit and skill that sets him apart from many of today's fantasy and sci-fi novelists. This keeps you turning the page as much as the desire to learn more about Kvothe - the words themselves just draw you in.
As for the structure of "The Wise Man's Fear", it is quite long (almost 1000 pages) and despite its length the story doesn't take any giant leaps forward. This can be seen as good or bad depending on how you expected this story to unfold. I suspect this story will go beyond the original "trilogy", which was at least rumoured. We certainly learn a lot more about how Kvothe thinks and what he is capable of.
To add some criticism: I believe some scenes (or extended scenes) went on longer than they needed to. I would have been just as happy with those parts pared down, possibly allowing other parts to be expounded (the journey to Vintas, for example).
All in all another wonderful read that you just can't put down. I can't wait for #3!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good, not as good as the first, July 15 2011
Really enjoyed the first in the series, I was excited to get back into this world and Mr. Rothfuss allowed us a larger glimpse of it. There were some slightly jarring elements of the story-telling which I felt could have been exciting if expanded upon, but I think that's just his style. I enjoyed this book, and finished it quickly. I can't wait to hear more about Kvothe's adventures!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No