Most helpful customer reviews
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Stop Studying, Start Writing, Mar 16 2004
This review is from: Writing Fiction (Paperback)
The steep price of this book gives away that it's a college textbook, not a book for the general reader. There are books for the novice out there that answer the same questions this book but cost you a lot less. But this really is better than most books. Rather than trying to address itself to writing globally or simply act as boosterism to get you busy, this book actually gets into the nuts and bolts of the writing craft. It answers questions about constructing narrative fiction that even experienced writers have from time to time. There's no fiddling business about comma use--there are other books for that--but for narrative structure, beginnings and ends, building tension, and more, this is your book. Many books of this type are laden with platitudes and aphorisms about writing. They're pretty, but they don't really help you get going. What really sets this book apart is that, after it gives you your standards and rules, it gives you excerpts from other writers' fiction to demonstrate how it works in the real world of published fiction. Now that's truly useful. All that said, it suffers from the same problem that afflicts all fiction-writing books: it can't really teach you how to write. It's okay to have this book at hand to answer your questions, give you tutorials, and work on fine-tuning, but the only way you'll really get good at writing is to stop studying books and start writing like you mean it. This book is good within the limitations that surround all fiction-writing books. To really succeed, you need to just knuckle down and write, but as you're doing that, this is the book to have within reach. Now stop reading my stupid review and start writing your fiction!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 8 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars
I wish I could give it a -5 stars, July 10 2004
This review is from: Writing Fiction (Paperback)
I am taking a class in Fiction Writing and this was one of the texts for the class. This book was touted as the be all and end all in assistance in the writing process. I couldn't wait to get my hands on this book. I found it used in the bookstore for $40 (remember, starving college student). I got it home and was astounded by what I read in the second paragraph. We were to read chapter 2 first. Well, let me tell you. I have never been so insulted in my entire life. "...it's probable that your impulse to write has little to do with the desire or the skill to work out a plot." (p27) EXCUSE ME?!?!?! It only goes down hill from there. This author is arrogant and leads one to believe that she is the only one capable of writing a story. I've attempted to read chapters 3, 4, 5, and 6 as they have been assigned in the class. It's complete torture to get through them. I will be selling my copy as soon as I possibly can.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
177 of 185 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Stop Studying, Start Writing, Mar 16 2004
By Kevin L. Nenstiel "omnivore" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Writing Fiction (Paperback)
The steep price of this book gives away that it's a college textbook, not a book for the general reader. There are books for the novice out there that answer the same questions this book but cost you a lot less. But this really is better than most books. Rather than trying to address itself to writing globally or simply act as boosterism to get you busy, this book actually gets into the nuts and bolts of the writing craft. It answers questions about constructing narrative fiction that even experienced writers have from time to time. There's no fiddling business about comma use--there are other books for that--but for narrative structure, beginnings and ends, building tension, and more, this is your book. Many books of this type are laden with platitudes and aphorisms about writing. They're pretty, but they don't really help you get going. What really sets this book apart is that, after it gives you your standards and rules, it gives you excerpts from other writers' fiction to demonstrate how it works in the real world of published fiction. Now that's truly useful. All that said, it suffers from the same problem that afflicts all fiction-writing books: it can't really teach you how to write. It's okay to have this book at hand to answer your questions, give you tutorials, and work on fine-tuning, but the only way you'll really get good at writing is to stop studying books and start writing like you mean it. This book is good within the limitations that surround all fiction-writing books. To really succeed, you need to just knuckle down and write, but as you're doing that, this is the book to have within reach. Now stop reading my stupid review and start writing your fiction!
40 of 45 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
For academic-literary writers only, Aug 29 2004
By bookloversfriend - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Writing Fiction (Paperback)
For would-be writers looking for a first book on fiction writing, this book is as good as any, provided and only provided that you are interested in writing what might be termed the academic-literary short story. For those interested in writing for readers (termed by academics the "popular" novel), this book could well be highly misleading. The fact that Burroway and others such as Macauley & Lanning think that the same basic principles apply but that "literary" fiction goes beyond--this fact shows that they understand neither popular fiction nor yet "literary" fiction. In fact, the two are based on diametrically opposed principles and have largely opposite criteria of quality. Also, bear in mind that you are getting only the ABCs in this book. This is a first book, not a last book. That said, the exposition is clear and there are numerous examples (all from academic-literary fiction). Whether it is worth the price--ah, that is another question.
38 of 53 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars
Too expensive and too general, Dec 30 2005
By M. McKenna "ChickieSidhe" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Writing Fiction (Paperback)
I used this book twice in two different classes, and it simply repeats everything one can find in a $20 creative writing book. The readings selected are lackluster or horribly common in creative writing books already. If this book were even $30, the content would not be so reprehensible. However, with the hefty price tag, the pages should be littered with helpful tips that are new and exclusive to this book. Burroway's "Imaginative Writing" is just as boring and hollow, but it at least does not gouge the pocket. I would reccomend not buying this book if one is looking for a creative writing book. Instead, check out "The First Five Pages" or "30 most common mistakes of Fiction Writers," both of which rest comfortably under the $20 marker. For those who are required to use this book for a class, either don't buy it or purchase an earlier edition.
|
|
|