8 of 9 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Amazing Anthology, Sep 16 2011
By J. Chambers "Giddeaon" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Year's Best Dark Fantasy & Horror, 2011 Edition (Paperback)
Anthologies can often be hit or miss, and at the very least one or more of the stories will be complete drivel. As I said, that is usually the case, but there is nothing usual or mundane about The Year's Best Dark Fantasy & Horror, 2011 Edition. The stories, each and every one, delighted and thrilled me. The wide breadth of examples of the two genres was astounding and well received. Far too often these kinds of compilations can be made to seem cookie cutter, each story being a reflection of the last. You'll find none of that blandness here, and it speaks volumes to the good taste and efforts of editor Paula Guran.
A few of the stand out pieces for me were written by Sarah Langan, Neil Gaiman, Tanith Lee and Holly Black. I have read both Langan and Gaiman before and was happy to see their usual high form. I was familiar with the reputations for Lee and Black and I can now see why they are both regarded so highly. While these four were my personal favorites, all of the other authors provided tales well worth reading. Each is a gem...a hideously weird, oddly monstrous, quietly beautiful gem.
10 of 12 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Mixed quality, too many reprints., Nov 26 2011
By Owen Florey - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Year's Best Dark Fantasy & Horror, 2011 Edition (Paperback)
For the most part I enjoyed this anthology with the strongest pieces being, for me, "Lesser Demons", "Hurt Me", "Raise Your Hand if You're Dead", "The Stars are Falling" (although this story is not actually any form of speculative fiction, it is still quite eerie and touching) "Oaks Park" and "Thimbleriggery and Fledglings". I slept through "Crawlspace" and a few others that took too long to get to any kind of point, along with the massive George R. R. Martin novella which didn't really feel dark enough to qualify for inclusion here. In addition, many of the stories by Big Name authors (Neil Gaiman, Gene Wolf and, arguably, Peter Watts) are reprints from Prime's Best Science Fiction and Fantasy 2011, and nearly all of the stories here are reprints from one anthology or another. Maybe there just aren't many publications left in the horror genre, but I would've liked to see more space dedicated to reprinting worthy works that would otherwise be lost to the recycling bin. Definitely worth the discounted Amazon price, unless you already have the original anthologies.
(Full contents:
Lesser Demons, Norman Partridge
Raise Your Hand if You're Dead, John Shirley
As Red As Red, Caitlin R Kiernan
Tragic Life Stories, Steve Duffy
The Naturalist, Maureen McHugh
The Broadsword, Laird Barron
A Thousand Flowers, Margo Lanagan
Frumpy Little Beat Girl, Peter Atkins
The Stars Are Falling, Joe R. Landsdale
Hurt Me, M.L.N. Hanover
Are You Trying To Tell Me This Is Heaven? Sarah Langan
Sea Warg, Tanith Lee
Crawlspace, Stephen Graham Jones
Mother Urban's Booke of Dayes, Jay Lake
Brisneyland By Night, Angela Slatter
The Thing About Cassandra, Neil Gaiman
He Said, Laughing, Simon R. Green
Bloodsport, Gene Wolf
Oaks Park, M.K. Hobson
Thimbleriggery and Fledglings, Steve Berman
You Dream, Ekaterina Sedia
Red Blues, Michael Skeet
The Moon Will Look Strange, Lynda E. Rucker
The Things, Peter Watts
Malleus, Incus, Stapes, Sarah Totton
The Return, S.D. Tullis
The Dog King, Holly Black
How Bria Died, Mike ARanovitz
The Dire Wolf, Genevieve Valentine
Parallel Lines, Tim Powers
The Mystery Knight: A Tale of The Seven Kingdoms, George R. R. Martin)