The Young Man's Guide is a very interesting read, providing us with some insights that still hold very true even decades later. It really does change our perspectives on many things of our everyday life.
Was this review helpful to you?
Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
17 of 24 people found the following review helpful
Stiff Rectitude to Us; Warm and Fuzzy to 1836.May 23 2010
J. P. Fisher
- Published on Amazon.com
This reviewer is not here going into detail, citings and/or rhetorical devices. Short and sweet.
Mr. Alcott's work is from the heart and it is inspired by the spirit of community improvement, which is one of the fundamental prinicples he proposes ought to be included in an American male's psyche as a key motivator.
That principle still has merit, as do many of the others he advances. On the very first page of Chapter One, he defines every man's purpose in life: "to be of the greatest possible usefulness." No problem.
Those guys seem always to have been producing something. They had no TV, no iPad, Kindle, smart phone, Google search, Bing (just for comparison.) But there were, as always, distractions. Handle them.
If you are conversant with contemporary thought and practice in parenting and aware of some developmental psychology - not that the reviewer so purports - as "MyCousin Vinnie" would say, "it holds water." (Granted, Alcott's era is nothing even close to recognizably touchy-feel-y, but he loves youth and says that kids playing is an absolute must- after the work is done, of course.)
Between what Alcott reports and what the informed reader already knows of boy character building, virtually all of the history of traditional American values is within grasp.
Keep in mind that not many people were eligible to vote then. Women CEO's could be counted on the fingers of no hands. Because of those anachronisms and more, I'd bet some unfortunates today will find the book laughable, as they judge Alcott by 2010 sensibilities. That's often a mistake.