1.0 out of 5 stars
just don't, April 29 2008
This review is from: Yours, Mine and Ours (Les Tiens, les Miens et les Nôtres) (Widescreen) (DVD)
i really disliked this movie. not only does the movie run on the stereotypical plot and themes of countless movies that have come before it... but it's based on a movie that was actually very good. i suppose i wouldn't mind this version so very much if i hadn't seen the lucille ball version first, it would have been just another crude attempt at mashing together a feel-good movie about family values to get people to pay money to go see it, like a lot of the other things playing in theaters. but since i've seen and enjoyed the original, watching this actually offended me personally. i would have preferred that they take these characters and make a new movie.. not attempt to ride on the success of the last one.
as for the movie itself, the mom was of course the with the big heart and the dad a heartless dictator, stereotypical gender roles ftw. the mom of course had to adopt a kid from every visually different racial category so that all races were represented... while making them play out their 'racial role', one chinese kid was an effeminate designer, the other tech savy, the indian kids went barefoot and liked gardening, the black kid was 'gangsta' and made a rap song for them all at one point, and of course all the white kids were the focus of the story ... so they reaaaallllyyyy tried hard to create dynamic and interesting characters here, and at the same time did a most excellent job of challenging the status quo and the stereotypes that influence kids to perpetuate racist stereotypes. honestly. there should be a committee or something for things like this. and of course the men made all the rules and the women had 'great personalities' aka 'strong' but did what the men said in the end. again, great film for the kids.
i'm getting a bit overly sarcastic now so i'll stop. suffice it to say i was not impressed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
disappointing in the comedy dept (2.5/5), Sep 17 2007
This review is from: Yours, Mine and Ours (Les Tiens, les Miens et les Nôtres) (Widescreen) (DVD)
Admiral Frank Beardsly(Dennis Quaid) marries his high school sweet
heart,Helen North(Rene Russo).thing is,he has 8 kids,and she has 10.his
kids are strait laced by the book,owing to growing up with an admiral
for a father.her kids are free spirited,with much more freedom of
expression due to their mothers influence.so,the families merge and
with the kids being total opposites,you would think this is a recipe
for disaster.well,it should have been.but for some reason,it just
doesn't seem to work.i think i laughed about 3 times.actually
'chuckled' is probably more accurate.the rest of the time,i just
waited, hoping for something funny to come along.and the typical
Hollywood ending didn't help much.now,this is not a horrible movie,in
fact it is entertaining at times,but i expected to laugh more,and based
on that,i give Yours,Mine and Ours 2.5/5
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
a bit disappointing in the comedy area, Mar 6 2007
i was a bit disappointed in this movie.i was hoping to be laughing hysterically.i did chuckle a few times and there is 1 very funny scene.other than that,it was amusing once in awhile.nevertheless,this is a good family movie and some people may find it hysterical.to each their own.my advice would be to rent it 1st to see for youself.it is certainly worth a rental.if you do enjoy this movie,you might also enjoy the 'Cheaper by the Dozen' movies with Steve Martin,which have a similar formula.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No