Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful
Neurotic eroticaOct. 5 2007
- Published on Amazon.com
True to form, Seijun Suzuki here delivers an over-the-top cinematic tour-de-force, set in Japan circa the 1930s, contrasting an intensely studious Japanese professor of German language and literature with an equally intense former classmate--who seems to have no real profession--in their desire for and manner of relating to the same two women, as well as a third, who may or may not be one of the other two. If this sounds confusing, welcome to the world of Seijun Suzuki!
As is the case with many, if not most Suzuki films, it's pretty tough to provide a linear plot summary. Suzuki is the master of hyperbolically elliptical cinema (how's that for a metaphoric description?) which he fuses with a B-movie sensibility that ultimately produces something truly unique. The professor's friend--a shaggy-haired guy who sometimes wears an eye patch, sometimes not--is possibly a serial killer, but that doesn't seem to be a critical plot point. But one thing he definitely is, and that's basically nuts. Wacko. Intense.
At the beginning of the film, the two men find the same geisha, O-ine. Both express their desire for her in their respective ways, and she finds favor with both. Ultimately, both men marry different women, but the nutcase guy marries a woman who looks exactly like O-ine--but it's not her.
Through the first two-thirds or so of the film, there's a really nutty Greek chorus supplied by three blind beggars--a young man, a young woman, and an old man. Upon first encounter, they all sing a crude song of lust, and then are seen arguing among themselves--mostly the two men fighting over the girl--as they make their way randomly through the world.
At one point, Mr. Nutjob accompanies them; he's not the kind to stay tied down for any length of time and is drawn to their bizarre little scenario. Later, the nutcase is seen almost naked sitting in the snow. As I said, you can't really describe a Suzuki film in any linear way, because it's not a linear film. Mr. Nutjob also deeply enjoys his friend's (the professor's) wife, and there is as well a strong pull from the nutcase's wife on the professor.
Nutjob has previously impregnated his wife who ultimately dies, and it's O-ine, the geisha, who finally comes to the Nutjob's house to take care of the baby. I won't reveal what happens closer to the end of the film because this is where even more wacky stuff happens.
This film was honored soon after its release with the Japanese equivalent of several Oscars and it's easy to see why. Suzuki was doing what nobody else in Japanese cinema did--or for that matter, what almost nobody else in world cinema did or even is doing today. This is a fascinating piece of work, whose title comes from a piece of music for violin written and played by Pablo Sarasate, which is heard at the beginning of and in various spots throughout the movie.
Really interesting and well worth seeing--if not owning.
Good film - poor video transferMarch 30 2012
- Published on Amazon.com
i always wanted to own a copy of Seijun Suzuki's Taisho Trilogy of which this is the first film. As I don't understand most Japanese language I have to watch a subtitled film a few times to get the full experience. I had to watch Ziguenerweisen several times to get the story straight. But I was "technically disappointed" because the video transfer is poor. I would not buy the rest of the trilogy from this series. I recently bought Yumeji, the third film of the trilogy, from another source and the video transfer was much superior to this offering.