Most helpful customer reviews
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
Another perspective on suicide, in a Dr Phil culture., July 25 2008
Fantastic read- Hornby tells the tale of four would-be suicide victims, as different as they can be, from each of their own perspectives. No sappy words or formula-fiction here: just a biting, witty take on something many people have thought about at one point or another. It's a serious issue, but Hornby write's about it so it becomes laugh-out-loud funny. One of the best contemporary novels I've read this year!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
4.0 out of 5 stars
3.5 Stars for a 'Good' Hornby Effort, Jun 3 2008
Nick Hornby is probably known best for "About a Boy" and "High Fidelity" but creedence should be given to his lesser-known efforts as well, such as this one, about a group of people meet on a rooftop on New Years Eve and have a common goal: to commit suicide for different reasons. Because of this commanality, form an interesting, complicated bond that changes throughout the novel through slow revelation and at times, laugh-out-loud dialogue.
The book seems shallow at first, a mockery of what is a serious psychological disorder. But the lighthearted tone of the novel is met halfway with brilliant moments of darkness and reflection, such as various moments involving middle-aged Maureen, who realizes her own stark loneliness while on vacation, and also comes to the revelation that she does not know how to truly live, having given her life to her disabled son and even moments of the rebellious, difficult (yet at times, annoying and unrealistic) Jess, who at the heart of her problems with her boyfriend and parents, misses her vanished sister. It seems Hornby makes a point of demonstrating that these characters are at odds with themselves in more ways than one, including their complicated friendship that sometimes seems to be of convenience but in the end, is a strong mutual bond of respect and love, even unbeknownst to the characters themselves.
At times, Hornby's writing style can be over-explicit and he allows little work for the reader while exposing, in very plain detail, characters' thoughts and revelations (for example, we do not necessarily need to be told that Jess wants her sister to come back - it is already implied; yet, Hornby goes into detail on the matter, making the book sometimes frustrating in its approach to the human psyche). As well, these characters and their situations are at times far-fetched and unbelieveable, despite being incredibly entertaining (such as when Jess tells tabloid magazines that the reason they spared their lives was because of an angel they saw). Although not without its problems, Hornby's always-entertaining dialogue makes for a great, complex, cerebral yet hilarious and lighthearted read that is sometimes so sad you forget that it's funny and sometimes so funny you forget that it's sad. What seems at first like a hopeless disregard for life's turns of events, in the end turns into a celebration of what rebirth, second chances, life and unexpected friendships can do for someone. It is definitely worth the read!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
I feel the very same way, Nov 1 2007
So many books come recommended to me from friends, the Internet, bestseller lists, etc, that it gets mind boggling sometimes just trying to tell who is right. Sure, I bought, read, and loved some of the ones recommended to me. Books like McCrae's Katzenjammer, Patterson's Lifeguard, and Kidd's Secret Life of Bees. I loved them-all different. But the premise of A LONG WAY DOWN. You CAN'T go wrong with that! What a knock-out idea for a book. And what the author does with this material is even better than the idea! The story begins with four people from very different backgrounds who use New Year's Eve, not as a time to make for resolutions for the coming year, but instead to resolve to end their lives by jumping off a building. Coming together at such a low point in their lives unites the foursome, which includes a down on his luck talk show host, an older woman caring for a disabled son, a teen girl who can't handle her first breakup, and an American guy in his 20s whose band broke up and girlfriend dumped him. As an English writer, Nick Hornby uses the American to show some of the cultural differences in language, which I found hilarious. Anyway, although they don't always get along, the group gives each other support, simply by sharing the same depressing feeling that there is nothing more to live for. Must also recommend the highly unusual KATZENJAMMER (Soon to be a major motion piciture) and the really bizarre and thoroughly enjoyable TIME TRAVELER'S WIFE, both which are equally as good as ALWD. I look forward to more books by Mr. Hornby as he's one heck of a great writer with wonderful ideas!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Most recent customer reviews
|