From Publishers Weekly
Examining the trouble the blank page presents to a writer?"beginning to tell a story is like making a pass at a stranger in a restaurant"?Israeli novelist Oz (Panther in the Basement, etc.) considers the methods authors use to draw readers into the "opening contracts" of a narrative. One oddity of this thin collection of essays, derived from talks at high schools and colleges, is that Oz has read each text in a Hebrew translation (except for a few Israeli writers who wrote in Hebrew to begin with), whether by Chekhov or Gogol, Theodor Fontane or Marquez, which presumably affects at least nuances, especially given that Oz focuses on such small portions of the texts. Oz's interest in discovering what the reader must accept to become entrapped in the tale is especially illuminating of Chekhov's "Rothschild's Fiddle" and Elsa Morante's History: A Novel. In other analyses?for instance, a Raymond Carver story or a Franz Kafka fantasy?extensive quotations only pad elaborations of the obvious. This short, if feisty and often amusing, book is ultimately sketchy, suggesting a longer study abandoned early in the going. It certainly would have been more fruitful if Oz had spent as much time contemplating middles and endings as he does fretting about beginnings.
Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Oz, one of Israel's finest writers (e.g., Panther in the Basement, LJ 8/15/97), has written a short guide to reading. Using the beginnings of various works, he explains how to intrepret text. He is especially interesting when discussing the Hebrew writers S.Y. Agnon, Yizhar, and Aharon Shabtai. In thinking about other writers, Oz gives insight into his own methods and style, explaining that the truthfulness and honesty of the narrator's voice is an important element in thinking about the work. Oz also explains how important it is to relate beginnings to the whole text. Besides the Hebrew authors, he considers Fontaine, Gogol, Kafka, Chekhov, Morante, Garcia Marquez, and Carver. A good job; buy for literature collections.?Gene Shaw, New York P.L.
Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.
