Commentaires client les plus utiles
|
|
3 internautes sur 3 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile :
4.0étoiles sur 5
Great Place to Start, Oct. 17 2005
Having never read an Ian Flemming novel, I felt it would be best to read his first book in the James Bond Series and the only one not yet made into a feature film. If you're only now beginning to read the novels, Casino Royale is the perfect book to read because it gives a bit of information about the James Bond Character. Through reading we find out how he became the man many of us know from the movies; such as his love of cars and how he obtained the 00 label. It's expected that the future Bond Film which is based on this book will also act as a prequel, so what better way to prepare yourself for the feature film then to read this fun novel that you can finish in about a day, and will certainly want you to follow up by reading the other novels in the series.
|
|
|
2.0étoiles sur 5
A Royale With Cheese, Jui 26 2004
I'm not the world's biggest fan of the James Bond movies, although I do enjoy them a bit. I've seen a handful of them in the cinema, and will gladly watch one on TV on a Sunday afternoon if there's no football on. But I'd heard good things about the novel series that the movies were based on and I was curious to see how James Bond worked in print. I'll probably read more books in the series, because I liked the style, but my overall impression of CASINO ROYALE, the first James Bond novel, was negative.The plot revolves around the need for government agent James Bond to beat a Russian spy decisively at the Baccarat table in a ritzy casino/vacation resort. It doesn't get much more complicated than that, although the sections of the book involving the initial stakeout and the game itself are satisfying and competent. They seem to be very influenced by the pulp thrillers that had come in years past, though they bring little new to the table. They're fun though. My main problem came once the initial conflict has been resolved, all the way at the two-thirds point. The final third of the book involves a bizarre romance and an even stranger set of ruminations on good vs. evil. This section is, to be frank, childishly inept, and ruins any good will I had stored up from the casino plot. Yes, deliberations on what separates agents working for the "good" guys and spies working for "evil" governments is an interesting idea and one which has sparked numerous thought-provoking debates and discussions. But this isn't one of them. James Bond himself isn't terribly developed yet; I assume his persona would become better established in subsequent novels. He's humorless, moody and drab. I never really felt there was enough to get a grip on the character. The rest of the cast are sketchy as well. Of course, since most of them are lesser agents who only show up when they have a plot point to fill, that's to be expected. Bond's love interest receives more characterization from her slinky portrait on the cover than from anything that appears in the pages. To be honest, I'm faintly surprised to hear rumors of Hollywood producers wishing to film this (on the premise that it's the last James Bond novel that hasn't been faithfully adapted to the screen). It seems to me it would be rather dull after the excesses recently displayed in the movies. There's only one explosion, a relatively tame car chase sequence, no helicopters, jet-planes, or space vehicles. In short, it's comparatively tame. Hopefully they'll adapt the better parts of the book (the gambling and casino intrigue) and cut out the bad (the last sixty or so pages). Merging the book's successes with the better-established characters may result in an entertaining film, but it has its work cut out for it if it wants to be great.
|
|
|
5.0étoiles sur 5
Fleming's Firstborn, Jui 22 2004
Par Un client
I enjoyed this book BECAUSE of some things that others seem to have had trouble with. Bond's falling in love characterizes him as a more complete person than the womanizer of later books and films. Le Chifre's relatively early demise worked okay for me because of the romance. It had a mystery element all its own. And,of course there were plenty of the usual James Bond antics: car chases, elegant evenings, martini drinks, and the inevitable scene where James is tied up and abused by the bad guys. Bravo for this first novel. And good to know that, despite Mr. Fleming's passing, the genre lives on. I am impressed that newcomer Thomas Hopp, with his debut book The Jihad Virus, may be picking up the mantle of Fleming complete with car chases, love, bullets, and a hero tied up and tormented. The two stories are very similar in effect, if not in plot.
|
|
|
Commentaires client les plus récents
|