Most helpful customer reviews
|
|
3.0 out of 5 stars
Pleasant but...not LM Montgomery's best., Aug 11 2009
LM Montgomery did not write the Anne books in order. Anne of Ingleside was written in 1939, after all of the other books, and while it does have its own charm, it also has to me the feeling of something hastily thrown together to please the author's fans.
The book opens with a few very lovely chapters showing Anne enjoying a week-long visit in Avonlea. These chapters have a bit of the flavour of the previous books, especially the part where Diana and Anne go on a picnic to one of their favourite places of yesteryear, Hester Gray's garden. But then Anne returns to the town of Glen St. Mary and her home, which they have named Ingleside. From that point on the book follows the family life of Ingleside over the course of the next 6 years. Sadly, we see no more of the Avonlea folk whatsoever. In fact we see very little of Anne or Gilbert either.
The bulk of the book follows the various scrapes and adventures of Anne's children as they grow up. Disappointingly, Anne's children seem to interact more with the housekeeper, Susan, than they do with their mother herself (Anne seems to be often away on social engagements). There is no cohesive plot whatsoever here--the book reads more like a collection of short stories, and it's sometimes difficult to discern where we are in the timeline, as season blends into season.
The back of the book talks about Anne wondering if Gilbert still loves her--this is not a central theme of the book at all, but rather the idea in the last few chapters when I suppose LM Montgomery decided she needed to return to Anne to wrap up the book, since the book began with her. Anne only feels dejected for one day, their anniversary, since it seems that Gilbert has forgotten it--but at the end of the day she finds she was wrong and then everything is right in Anne's world. She does nothing whatsoever to "make her husband fall in love with her all over again" as it states on the back of the book.
One thing that irked me, is that in the end of the book they meet up with Christine Stuart, and talk about how Gilbert used to be her beau. But in Anne of the Island, Gilbert clearly states that there was never anything between he and Christine, people just assumed he was her beau...I suppose since so much time passed between the writing of those books the author forgot about what she had previously written. Forgiveable, but still annoying to a reader going through the books all at once.
Anyhow, although I did not feel this book was very well organized or well written, some of the stories within it were very cute, and I did like the parts that included Anne as well. I gave it three stars, although I'd like to give it 3.5 if I could, because I did enjoy some parts of it quite a bit (the image of six-year old Rilla throwing the cake into the brook is particularly memorable).
Overall, I would recommend this book only to die-hard Anne fans. If you are a more casual reader, I would recommend the first three Anne books, followed by Anne's House of Dreams (which actually does have a storyline) and then Rilla of Ingleside, which follows Anne's youngest daughter during the days of World War 1.
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wonderful, Dec 27 2002
If you like Anne of Green Gables in any way, you have to read the other books in order to see her grow up. She stills continue to get in trouble, romance with Gilbert continues, just about anything that can happen, happens. These books fulfill everything that you could ever want out of a book.
|
|
|
2.0 out of 5 stars
Bland and more than a bit disappointing..., May 31 2002
When I was finally able to pick up a copy of this book, I was quite excited to read more of Anne's continuing adventures. Up to this point, I had found myself enthralled by all of Anne's adventuring. But when I finally managed to finish this book, it really was a disappointing moment. The book revolves, mostly, around the adventures of Anne's children, none of which were in the least bit interesting. Her children's stories all follow one main plotline. 1: I'm going to be naughty even though mother and everyone says I should be good. 2: Oh, it really was horrible wanting to be naughty, because it all turned out badly in the end. 3: Mother's holding me and everything's all better again. About half way through the book, I really began to wonder how two such interesting characters as Anne and Gilbert could have possibly had not 1, but 6 dull, rather stupid, flighty children. Even their imaginings, which, in Anne seemed so interesting, were all terribly lackluster and idiotic in her children. There was absolutely no character development of Anne or Gilbert, which, I rather felt there should have been, considering the book takes place over quite a number of years. Anne is nothing more than window dressing, brought in and out of the scenes in the most haphazard fashion. Gilbert spends the entire book going from work to more work, and yet another spat of work, before starting it all over again. Everything that I enjoyed so much about their earlier romance was gone completely, and the end, to which the back of the book aludes is flat at best. Anne does nothing to 'win' Gilbert's love all over again. It's practically all of one chapter. 1: Anne has a fit, and is sure Gilbert no longer loves her(which, if I were writing Gilbert, considering how utterly boring Montgomery writes her out to be, would be completely understandable). 2: Anne gets jealous. 3: Anne and Gilbert come home and suddenly everything's right in the world again. I was thankful to finally finish this book, something I've never felt with the first 5. With those it was always, Good grief, it's over already? All in all, if you're HUGE Anne fan, you might want to read this book simply to have read another book into which Anne figures. But don't expect her to be anything like the old Anne so many came to love and respect.
|
|
|
Most recent customer reviews
|