From Publishers Weekly
S-Day is the code name for a Nazi invasion of Britain launched in 1942--a fictional 1942, when Hitler, instead of attacking Russia, husbands his resources for the conquest of England. The blow falls on the small American expeditionary force sent to England in the aftermath of Pearl Harbor. Step by step the GIs are driven back until their commander, General Wilson Clay, is faced with a choice that will change the course of history. Thayer ( Ringer ) loses charge of his story, which variously seems an alternate history, a novel on the psychology of command and a military adventure. Instead of learning how the Germans gain air superiority, mount the assault and fight their way inland, readers are given vignettes of men in battle drawn from the common stock of military fiction; Clay himself is merely a collection of mannerisms. Factual errors, such as incorrect order of battle and inaccurate descriptions of weapons and tactics, further diminish the novel's appeal to readers interested in what might have been.
Copyright 1990 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
What if Hitler had invaded England? And what if a charismatic American general like Patton had led the defense? These are the questions posed by Thayer ( Pursuit , LJ 3/1/86) in his latest novel. General Wilson Clay, commander of the American Expeditionary Force in England, is the Patton-like leader whose responsibility it becomes to fight the Germans on the beaches and beyond with bulldog determination. As the Nazis advance, Clay is forced to make difficult decisions that affect his troops and the local population, including the alluring Lady Anne Percival. The novel is primarily an overlong battle narrative and character study. Readers interested in alternative history will find it entertaining, but for most fiction collections it is a marginal purchase.
- William C. McCully, Park Ridge P.L., Ill.Copyright 1990 Reed Business Information, Inc.
