Commentaires client les plus utiles
|
|
9 internautes sur 10 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile :
4.0étoiles sur 5
"One reads for pleasure, It's not a public duty.", Déc 3 2007
Her Royal Highness Queen Elizabeth II is now 81 years of age and is in her 55th year on the throne. She remains one of the world's longest-serving heads of state, including the Head of the Commonwealth of Nations and Supreme Governor of the Church of England. Today she is one of the world's most photographed women and is often seen at home, living a quiet life with her prized pet Corgis. Certainly it is this blend of her sense of regal duty with a love of simple pleasures that have come so uniquely to characterize the style of her reign.
Elizabeth II has rarely made her political views public, but is believed to be moderately liberal in her outlooks and views. Imagined then a work of fiction that reads like an autobiography, which can somehow vivaciously bring her prophetic words and her innermost thoughts to life and delicately portray this exclusive and isolated world in which she inhabits. Author Alan Bennett certainly succeeds at this with his novella An Uncommon Reader giving us a deliciously funny and rather wicked birds-eye-view of the Queen and the way that she, and the Monarchy, would ever be transformed if she became hooked on reading.
It all starts when Elizabeth decides to take her beloved dogs for a walk in the palace gardens where she happens upon the City of Westminster traveling library, which looks to be in the shape of a large removal-like van parked next to the bins outside of one of the kitchen doors. This isn't a part of the palace that the Queen sees much of, and determined to apologize for the din that her dogs are currently causing she goes up to the van where she meets Mr. Hutchings, the traveling library's caretaker.
The Queen of course, has never taken much of an interest in reading, her feeling that liking books is "something that should be left to other people." After all, reading is a merely hobby and it is the nature of her job that she doesn't have hobbies. But with her sense of duty flourishing, she decides to so the right thing and actually borrow a book. Mr. Hutchings, encouraged by the young Norman Seakins, a young kitchen hand, ends up giving The Queen a copy of an Ivy-Compton-Burnett title even as he reflects, while shutting up the van and driving away, that a novel by "Dame Ivy is going to take quite a bit of reading."
Thus begins Elizabeth's journey into the world of reading. The Queen, is of course, assisted by the young Norman who she suddenly promotes to the status of literary advisor, mainly because he behaves uninhibited around her and seemed incapable of being anything else but himself. As her reading grows, she becomes familiar with the lives of famous writers such as E M Forster, but what she mostly finds is how one book leads to another and that doors keep opening wherever she turns. The days just aren't long enough for the reading that she wants to do.
Her private secretary Sir Kevin Scatchard, an over-conscientious New Zealander of whom great things were expected, becomes rather concerned with Her Majesty's newfound propensity, especially when she starts to recommend good reads to her at their weekly meetings. For her books just a reflection of the world, or a version of it. But poor Sir Kevin views books as merely about passing the time. Having discovered the delights of reading for herself, The Queen is keen to pass it on, particularly to her chauffeur, Summers and to all of the members of her extended family.
Soon the Queen is abandoning her long lines of inquiry of her subjects and embarking on a new conversational gambit about books to which very few of Her Majesty's loyal subjects had an answer. She reads more and more, beginning to draw her books from various other libraries including some of her own. Sir Ken feels the pursuit is selfish and solipsistic, even as he tries to harness her reading to some larger purpose. The Queen however, will not be swayed: "one reads for pleasure, It's not a public duty."
Although The Uncommon Reader is only one hundred and twenty pages and sometimes stretching the realms of credibility, the book still offers up a fascinating portrait of a wry, intelligent and funny woman who has a wicked sense of humor and who doesn't suffer fools gladly. Unquestionably this novel is as much about the Queen's personal growth as a woman and as an intellect than anything else, as books enable her to gain in an understanding of both literature and human nature. Mike Leonard December 07.
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles
Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ?
|
|
|
|
|
|
2 internautes sur 2 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile :
5.0étoiles sur 5
Delightful read, Oct. 16 2008
This is a wonderful book, full of humour, about the love of reading. Allan Bennett has the Queen herself become born again with the greatest literature of the ages. Behind the story is the message that books and reading are one of life's greatest, simplest pleasures especially in this technological age and that all of us, common and uncommon, can enjoy it.
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles
Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ?
|
|
|
|
|
|
5.0étoiles sur 5
A Paean to Reading: A Novella That Leaves You Wishing for More and Making Up Your Own Endings, Fév 1 2010
"When they had read it, they rejoiced over its encouragement." -- Acts 15:31
When The Uncommon Reader came out, the reviews I read made the book and its premise seem dull and uninteresting. I avoided it.
At my annual physical last month, my physician (who normally restricts his non-medical reading to things like the instructions on boxes of oatmeal) told me that this was the best book he had read in many years . . . and wouldn't let me out of the office without borrowing his copy. I was hooked. What could possibly be so interesting to him?
I think that those who tell you about the contents of this novella do you a disservice. I haven't read a review that does more than parrot the plot . . . which is to miss the point of the book.
Reading changes people for the better . . . even those who don't read. That's what this book is about. As you read The Uncommon Reader, I'm sure you'll be mentally reviewing the non-fiction story of your own life and how reading has changed you and those around you. Alan Bennett opens a closed door to many minds that have lost their sense of wonder about the power of the written word.
I particularly enjoyed the quirkier conjectures in the novella, ones that caused me to remember with great laughter times when others have been baffled by book-based comments and questions I've shared with them. It was like suddenly seeing a movie of my own life, filled with its most humorous moments.
The book ends before you've had your fill, leaving you wanting more. And you'll find more . . . by mentally continuing the story to where you would like to see it go. It's one of the most powerful endings for causing me to think that I remember since I first read Frank Stockton's short story, The Lady or the Tiger.
Run, don't walk, to get this book, now!
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles
Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Commentaires client les plus récents
|