From Publishers Weekly
Gordon R. Dickson fans were used to years of anticipating each installment in the Childe Cycle, begun with
Dorsai! in 1959, but they may not feel this latest volume, completed by Wixon after Dickson's death in 2001, is worth the 13-year wait. The "classic" space-opera vibe of the series is sliding rapidly toward "outdated," complete with heavy oversized void pistols, planetary shielding and a lone female protagonist, the inscrutable Antonia Lu, who exists mostly to agree and sleep with her half-brother, Bleys Ahrens. The creepily persuasive Bleys, last seen in
Other (1994), is increasingly megalomaniacal, so obsessed with his plan to save the human race that his uncle's disapproval and his brother's possible betrayal barely register. In Wixon's hands, Dickson's journalistic style becomes long stretches of exposition punctuated by disaster. SF readers who have come to care about Bleys may be unable to turn away from his slow moral decline; newcomers are unlikely to be captivated by it.
(Mar.) Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From Booklist
The specialized humans of the Splinter cultures are evolving to be responsible. But Splinter renegade Bleys Ahrens believes in
H. superior, not
H. responsible, and has followers on key worlds misdirecting information and resources to short-circuit that evolution. Bleys' formerly clear vision of what he was trying to do has, however, degenerated into intrigue for its own sake, and
H. superior could destroy the rest of humanity. Working from the late Dickson's notes, Wixon adds the eleventh and penultimate volume to the Childe Cycle. If not up to Dickson's standards, it at least augurs that the series will be concluded.
Roland GreenCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
