Commentaires client les plus utiles
|
|
5.0étoiles sur 5
Comic retelling of '65 saucer flap, Sep 3 2000
In the mythology that has grown up around unidentified flying objects, Ann Arbor was the place to be in 1966, when a variety of strange lights were spotted in the skies above the University of Michigan. In the days before the Internet, cable television, tabloid news shows, news of the sightings were slow to spread, and the story has taken on a life of its own. Flash forward to the present day, when summer school student and reporter Zoe Kaplan sees a triangle of lights whizzing through the sky. Her article makes USA Today and sets off a media firestorm that also attracts a wide variety of nut cases, including a paramilitary unit who had seen "Mars Attacks" too many times, a New Ager who channels the alien K-Tel, and a college professor who may or may not have found a way to prove that aliens really exist. Susan Holtzer captures the madness and, well, silliness that surrounds a story that takes on a life of its own. While there are mysteries to be solved in "The Silly Season," its primary pleasures lay in revealing saucer mythology to those of us who had let our subscriptions lapse to Popular Science (my primary source of UFO information during the 60s) and Fate magazines. Bet you didn't know America signed a treaty with the aliens in 1954, allowing them to build secret bases and carry on human abductions and experiments. In between sightings and factional infighting among the true believers, Holtzer also sneaks in the rationalist point of view as explained by the Snorg Hypothesis (which, at its heart, is the fact that you can't prove a negative). Lost in all the action is her detecting couple, police lieutenant Karl Genesko and his fiancee Anneke Haagen, but that's all right. It's really the story of how Kaplan learns that pitfalls of ambition in the pursuit of a story, and I can't tell you how nice it feels to meet a character who gives a credible imiation of a reporter. "The Silly Season" is a hoot of a book, and the temptation to read parts of it aloud is hard to resist. Those who believe that the "X-Files" is a documentary will find this offensive in the extreme. To the rest of us, "The Silly Season" is a wild carnival ride into the middle of a media whirlwind and out the other side.
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles
Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ?
 
|
|
|
|
|
|
5.0étoiles sur 5
Lots of fun, Jui 22 2000
"The Silly Season" is a lighthearted, entertaining and, yes, silly mystery that centers around UFO sightings during the summer term at the University of Michigan. Are extraterrestrials responsible or is it all an elaborate hoax? And who murdered the ufologist history professor? This well-written spoof really is great fun. Among the targets sent up are UFO freaks, postmodernists, New Agers, animal-rights extremists, "victim" groups demanding reparations, news reporters, conspiracy theorists, true believers generally, and even the professional skeptics whose viewpoint the author shares. And if you don't already know what the Snorg Hypothesis is, you can find out by reading this book.
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles
Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ?
|
|
|
|
|
|
2.0étoiles sur 5
"The Silly Season" is a silly book., Avril 12 2000
Susan Holtzer's other University of Michigan mysteries are a joy to read: Anneke and Karl are well developed, likeable characters and the University setting is an integral part of the unfolding of events. But "The Silly Season" doesn't continue with the same fine writing and skill. Holtzer admits she's trying for a 'farce', an entr'acte, something light and humorous. What she ends up with is a monumental bore. The murder (of a character so poorly developed we don't much care whether he's dead or not) is set among some supposed UFO sightings, and the action is populated by some cartoon-like, one dimensional Believers, who squabble among each other like hungry ducks fighting over breadcrumbs of ideas. Anneke and Karl are back--the policeman and his fiancee whom he improbably invites to witness all kinds of action--and Zoe the student reporter and her superficial friends. The story is bogged in UFO lore, and shallow people argue and play tricks on each other and somebody even murders one of them. But by the time the reader discovers that the UFOs are a lie and the murder is real, the book has degenerated to a farce and the only truth is his yawn.
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles
Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Commentaires client les plus récents
|
