Commentaires client les plus utiles
|
|
5.0étoiles sur 5
Fantastic, Jui 18 2004
Par Un client
I had a small idea of what i was in for after reading the reviews for this book. I had no idea how well researched Tim Powers was on everything. I highly recommend reading the notes about the book afterward, it is incredible how he uses so much real history and just how little he fills in the gaps with absurd fiction. And even the fantasy part is based on legends of Saudi Arabia, I'm talking about the Djjin, which are demon creatures.
The demons in this story are not your horrorific demons with red horns and fangs. These demons are seen more of as forgotten and lost angels, very complicated as a race, and very real. Throughout the story, we visit the lost city of Wabar (might also be called Sodom and Ghomorrah) Mt. Ararat, and many other places.
This book is stimulating on many levels, and you really get the idea that Powers was trying to make this novel a lot more than just a novel that gets one point across. The story is about secret governemnt cover ups and ancient histories linked to today, but what I thought when i read this book, interestingly enough, is that all of that fantasy aspect was really just a scenerio to run along a love story. Underneath all of the adventure and complication, in the end, this story ends up a simple story about a boy and a girl. It's an adolescent fantasy that takes our main character, Andrew Hale, as a spy at the age of 18, falling in love with another young spy named Elena, who he must partner with. After they are separated for twenty years is when the story of Ararat, and the Djjin really picks up, and by the end of the book, you get the vibe that that was all introductory to what happens at the end.
The climax of the story surrounding the Djjin on Mt. Ararat I thought was a little abrubt, but again, I don't think that was supposed to be the main and most important aspect of the book. The ending AFTER that is brilliant and is one of the most satisfactory endings I've read in a long time, in a long stream of quickly ended books. I had to re-read the very last paragraph of the book several times because it was so brilliant.
I highly recommend this book if you like stuff that's very historical, or if you like stuff that's very whacky, or if you just want a simple story about a spy and his long lost love. I stress that you can't be easily offended if you want to read this book. They toy with a lot of things in religion, like The Bible and The Koran. I am a christian, and i liked this book. I'm just saying that they present some ideas about the origin of The Ark (the one we think we know of, anyway) and Solomon's splitting of the baby proposal, that are very bizzare, just to name a few. But I highly recommend it.
|
|
|
5.0étoiles sur 5
Astonishingly good!, Mai 15 2004
I started reading "Declare" with a great deal of scepticism. I had previously read "Stranger Tides" and "Anubis Gate," and was very leery of what looked like it was going to be a standard spy story. OY! What a surprise! I plowed through the entire book in only three days! Powers doesn't get around to putting a firm identification of the What behind the mysterious goings-on of Operation Declare until page 160, but by then he has laid a firm groundwork of interesting characters and events of which the reader wants to learn more. Once we learn something in "Declare," however, Powers builds on it, and builds beautifully. Although "Declare" deals with Andrew Hale and Elena for hundreds of pages, it's actually inspired by (seemingly minor character) Kim Philby, and, in his afterward, Powers states that his intent was to write a novel about Philby which explored his life and work without changing any of the well-known facts of Philby's life. Its the interpretation which Powers puts on the events of Philby's life which make "Declare" mind-bogglingly good. Who, after all, REALLY knows what goes on in the deepest, darkest recesses of the world of espionage? Maybe some of the weirdness of the Looking Glass World really is due to a supernatural element, and if that supernatural element happened to be extremely ancient.... The title "Declare," which hardly compels at first, DOES make sense. Don't miss the reference to Job near the beginning of the book ("Declare, if thous hast understanding...."), and note the reactions of various characters to the word's use, and you won't be surprised yourself when the word turns up with greater frequency in various dialogues. One of the habits of Powers as a writer is his dropping of clues willy-nilly in plain sight, clues which only become significant when they've been seen again and again from different angles. In some books this has been an annoyance; in "Declare" it is a virtue and an art. (Consider the recurring phrase, "O Fish ..." -- at first it is gibberish in a dream, then begins to make sense, and then takes on a meaning so terrible that merely hearing the words can kill.) From the Cotswolds to Cairo to the Rub al-Khali; from Paris to Berlin to al-Kuwait; from Beiruit to Mount Ararat to Moscow, "Declare" weaves around the world of The Great Game in Europe and the Middle East, and jumps backwards and forwards in time with breath-taking rapidity, but Powers has learned his craft well, and "Declare" never disappoints. The number of "slow" pages numbers less than a dozen among 600+ pages. I highly recommend this book to anyone who has any interest in thrillers, spy novels, histories, or the supernatural. It straddles all of those genres with ease. Although it makes no reference to the "Cthulhu Mythos," it would fit snugly into any "Cthulhu Now" framework, and Powers is a far better writer than most of the Mythos writers, including H. P. Lovecraft himself.
|
|
|
5.0étoiles sur 5
Leads this reader back to "Kim", Avril 28 2004
Par Un client
"Declare" so intrigued me that I not only re-read it a year later, but, inspired by Powers' epigrams from Kipling's "Kim," went back to read that as well. I'm glad I did, because it's easy to view "Kim" as source material for much of what emerges in "Declare" -- the spiritual, otherworldly, military and political realms are blended in both works. If you enjoyed one, you'll enjoy the other.
|
|
|
Commentaires client les plus récents
|
