Most helpful customer reviews
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
Better than a high school education!, May 8 2007
For a book to be considered "good", especially a non-fiction book, it must meet a few basic requirements: It should be interesting and informative first of all. It should be fluid, flowing smoothly from one topic to the next without gaps or tangles in the narrative. And it should be entertaining. For a book to be considered "great", it should change the way you think about the world, maybe even change how you think about yourself and your own life.
Bill Bryson's "A Short History of Nearly Everything", by these standards, would be considered a great book. From the opening chapters to the last pages, you are led slowly down the path of history from the beginning--the universe at large, to the ending--man himself. The chapters flow smoothly indeed, and you are never left wanting to skip over the "boring" or "confusing" parts. There are no boring parts. And even the most complicated concepts, the deepest understandings we have about the science of the reality we find ourselves in, are explained in the simplest possible terms that leave you, not confused or bewildered, but awed that you actually get it, and when you don't get it, Bryson reassures you by explaining that even the most brilliant minds in the world don't really get it either. At certain points in the narrative though (a few points in each chapter for me), you must lay the book down on your chest for a moment and stop in awe and the glory and mystery of the universe.
The book is long and deep and fascinating, but the most prominent theme Bryson keeps returning to is how very little mankind actually knows about the universe, from the cosmic level on down to the microscopic level, and everything in between. Most of the stuff the brightest minds in the world think they know about our world is merely "best guesses", assumptions, or even blind stabs in the dark. It's very humbling. Yet it's also inspiring. You're left with the feeling that there's still so much left of the universe to discover, so much to figure out, so many areas of knowledge yet to explore.
The broad range of topics covered in this book is dazzling as well. Bryson looks and nearly all fields of science, from cosmology, to physics, to oceanography, to chemistry, to biology, to geology--far too many to list here--with a sweeping examination of the history behind them, how each science was born and developed, and by whom, and the delightful and often hilarious anecdotes behind them. Did you know for example, that matches, the kind used to light cigarettes, were invented by a man trying to convert urine into gold? I didn't, but I laughed out loud when I read it. And this wasn't the only time. The book is full of such gems. I laughed out loud at numerous occasions while reading this, and got a few funny looks from people on the bus and in the coffee shop where I was reading.
Flaws? Well, if you consider it a flaw, this book gets a tad alarming at some points. I wouldn't recommend it for younger readers. We live on a planet, in a universe that doesn't entirely seem to want us here, Bryson explains, and he gives very convincing proof in many different ways of the absolute precariousness of our existence. It can be frightening. It's enough to make you lay awake at night. But is it a flaw? I don't think so. It opens your eyes to the beauty of life in this world the way a near-death experience might. It challenges complacency and ingratitude.
Overall, I have to admit I learned more from this one book than I did my entire high school education. No exaggeration. I honestly believe this should be required reading for every high school student in the English-speaking world. I plan to get copies for my own children when they're older, and for my nephew and niece.
This book gave me a new perspective, new respect for the frailty and preciousness of life, and a new appreciation for the world outside my window when I get out of bed each morning. That's the best you can hope for in a book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
4.0 out of 5 stars
Pleasant read, but dubious credibility, July 28 2006
The book certainly is well-written and mostly clearly explained, and I also found the sense of humor and irony befitting. But there are two problems I've noticed.
One is that many issues, probably out of considerations of neatness, are not explained fully, leaving me wondering how and why it should be the case.
Another is that some accounts, maybe for the purpose of giving general impressions, are most probably inaccurate. In one instance, the author claimed that every week the earth is narrowly missed by a few asteroids (of a certain size), like a bullet hitting the sleeve yet missing the person, but for millions of years the earth simply isn't actually hit by any one of them. I find it contradicting the probabilistic common sense, if one is to take the metaphor seriously. The misses must in large part not be so narrow. This leaves me often wondering whether I should be able to trust the science the book is giving.
Still, as a layman I learned a lot from the book and enjoyed the time I spent reading immensely. It's a wonder how both scientific progress and scientific character can interwind into those sympathetic and engaging accounts.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
Not quite everything, but enough, Nov 24 2005
I was first acquainted with Bill Bryson through his works on the English language and various travelogue types of books. In these books he proved to be an entertaining writer, witty and interesting, with just the right amount of I'm-not-taking-myself-too-seriously attitude to make for genuinely pleasurable reading. Other books of his, 'Notes from a Small Island' and 'The Mother Tongue', are ones I return to again and again. His latest book, one of the longer ones (I was surprised, as most Bryson books rarely exceed 300 pages, and this one weighs in well past 500), is one likely to join those ranks. Of course, a history of everything, even a SHORT history of NEARLY everything, has got to be fairly long. Bryson begins, logically enough, at the beginning, or at least the beginning as best science can determine. Bryson weaves the story of science together with a gentle description of the science involved - he looks not only at the earliest constructs of the universe (such as the background radiation) but also at those who discover the constructs (such as Penzias and Wilson). A great example of the way Bryson weaves the history of science into the description of science, in a sense showing the way the world changes as our perceptions of how it exists change, is his description of the formulation, rejection, and final acceptance of the Pangaea theory. He looks at figures such as Wegener (the German meteorologist - 'weatherman', as Bryson describes him) who pushed forward the theory in the face of daunting scientific rejection that the continents did indeed move, and that similarities in flora and fauna, as well as rock formations and other geological and geographical aspects, can be traced back to a unified continent. Bryson with gentle humour discusses the attitudes of scientists, as they shifted not quite as slowly as the continents, towards accepting this theory, making gentle jabs along the way (Einstein even wrote a foreword to a book that was rather scathing toward the idea of plate tectonics - brilliance is no guarantee against being absolutely wrong). Bryson traces the development of the universe and the world from the earliest universe to the formation of the planet, to the growing diversity of life forms to development of human beings and human society. Inspired by Natural History (the short history refers more to natural history than anything else), this traces the path to us and possible futures. Bryson juxtaposes the creation of the Principia by Isaac Newton with the extinction of the dodo bird - stating that the word contained divinity and felony in the nature of humanity, the same species that can rise to the heights of understanding in the universe can also, for no apparent reason, cause the extinction of hapless and harmless fellow creatures on earth. Are humans, in Bryson's words, 'inherently bad news for other living things'? He recounts many of the truly staggering follies of species-hunting, particularly in the nineteenth century, calling upon people to take far more care of the planet with which we have been entrusted, either through design or fate. Bryson's take on things is innovative and his narrative is interesting, but there is a point to it, just as there is with most of his writing. He writes not merely to entertain, or to inform, but to persuade. Bryson is intrigued by science, having a joy that comes across the page of someone who essentially did not know or understand a lot of the background of science and how it worked in the world until recently, and now wants to share that joy with everyone! He definitely has points to argue - for starters, the need for open-mindedness, even among (perhaps particularly among) those who are supposed to have the open and searching intellects, the scientists themselves. He also wishes others to know more about science, professionals and laypersons, and more about our own origins as a people, both in terms of where we've come from, and how we've come to know about it. This is a new version of his already-published text, this time with graphics, paintings, pictures, maps and other things that make the history come alive in new and interesting ways. This is a good revision, adding quite a bit to Bryson's already interesting text. Unique among Bryson's writing in many ways, this is in some ways a travelogue through geology, paleontology, cosmology and evolution. A fun and fascinating read!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|