|
|
5 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Please finish writing BEFORE sending book to printer, Oct 21 2004
By A Customer
I quite liked Kathy Reichs' other books--the plots are usually nicely complex, and she is absolutely at her best when she has Tempe unravel the mysteries using forensic anthropology. This time, things have really gone downhill: (1) The characterization is just silly--the mysterious goings-on of Andrew Ryan puzzle, anger and hurt Tempe, but this highly intelligent woman doesn't simply ASK him what's going on? Are we supposed to believe that suddenly she has the self-confidence and/or petulance of an infatuated early teenager? And someone of her intelligence is supposed to go charging ALONE, of her own volition, into...well, you can read this part for yourself. But I warn you, it's utterly implausible. (2) We know that short sentence fragments and lots of brief dialogue can quicken the pace of a story, but Reichs WAY overuses this device--it goes on for pages and pages, numerous times in the book. The result looks as though she published her notes for the novel instead of finishing the novel itself. (3) About the use of French for "local colour": I'm a bilingual anglophone originally from Montreal, and I was actually offended at the number of misspellings and syntactical errors that were not proofread out. Gille? Contra? Did someone say Reichs is fluent in French? Not on your life. If you're going to sprinkle the book with French phrases, PLEASE do it right--at the very least, get a proofreader to help you. I would like to think that it's deadline pressure from the publisher, rather than Reichs herself, that is responsible for this piece of sloppy workmanship. I MUCH prefer Patricia Cornwell's Kay Scarpetta books these days--fascinating forensic medicine and FAR better and more subtle characterization, dialogue, and plotting. I'm eagerly awaiting the next Kathy Reichs book and hoping it will be done with more time, effort and attention to detail--like her other books.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|