The Tarim Mummies: Ancient China and the Mystery of the Earliest Peoples from the West: Amazon.ca: J. P. Mallory, Victor H. Mair: Books

Descriptions du produit

Brian Fagan

A major contribution to the history and archaeology of a remote and little known part of the world.

Colin Renfrew

Facinating and well-researched...certain to prove controversal.

Voir toutes les Descriptions du produit

Dans ce livre (les détails)

Parcourir les pages �chantillon
Plat recto | Table des mati�res | Extrait | Index | Plat verso

Associer des mots-cl�s � ce produit

(De quoi s'agit-il ?)

Consid�rez votre mot-cl� comme une sorte d'�tiquette d�finissant parfaitement ce produit.
Les mots-cl�s aident les clients � organiser et trouver leurs articles favoris.

L'avis des consommateurs

9 �valuations

5 �toiles:		(4)
4 �toiles:		(2)
3 �toiles:		(3)
2 �toiles:		(0)
1 �toiles:		(0)

�valuation du client type

4.1�toiles sur 5 (9 �valuations de client)

Partagez votre opinion avec les autres clients:

Cr�er votre propre commentaire

Commentaires client les plus utiles

3.0�toiles sur 5 If you found this book too dull, Nov. 4 2002

Par	rkb "rkb@hvc.rr.com" (Wallkill, NY United States) - Voir tous mes commentaires

read Elizabeth Wayland Barber's "Mummies of Urumchi" instead. It's a great read. She foucses on what we can learn about these people based on (starting from) the textiles the mummies were wrapped in. The result is a fascinating look at a surprising culture. And if you enjoy that, try her earlier book "Women's Work: the First 20,000 Years" too.

Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ? Oui Non (Signaler ce commentaire)

4.0�toiles sur 5 A fascinating look at one of our modern mysteries., Jui 12 2002

Par	Cas (the Idaho mountains) - Voir tous mes commentaires

This thick volume attempts to answer the question of how a bunch of Caucasian mummies ended up in central China. Scholarly and far-reaching, it delves into linguistics, archaeology, religion, and other disciplines.

It didn't actually dwell on the mummies of Tarim much. Most of it's book scholarship, not field investigation. It tries to show how various populations in China got where they did, using whatever means it can. In this regard, it succeeds. But I wish it'd talked about the actual mummies more than it did. I got occasional glimpses, but nothing more.

Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ? Oui Non (Signaler ce commentaire)

3.0�toiles sur 5 Lots of academic theorizing to reade, sometimes engaging., Mars 18 2002

Par Un client

...what it is, mainly, is a discussion about the cultural name and the language of the mummies might be. This is fine, and should occupy a chapter, but half the book is specifically related to trying to pin down a name out of Chinese and European sources and where they came from from archaeological and linguistic knowledge.

It seemed to me that the book might better have concentrated on what could be learned of their culture from what we DO know from their burials and with comparisons to how people live in those regions today. There is no in-depth analysis of the items (beyond what you can see for yourself in the photographs) nor comparison of cultural details or even explaining what a nomadic lifestyle would be like, nor discussion of specific practices that might suggest their beliefs. And when mention is made it is done briefly so they can get on with their analysis of the historical basis of Central Asia. Clearly they chose their emphasis simply because they have such limited access to the mummies themselves.

There are several chapters at the end that spell out all the competing ideas of how the Tarim basin may have been populated, which probably belonged in a anthropological journal. But I cannot say the book is not interesting to reade, its just that I kept waiting for a close study of cultural comparisons right until the book ended. For this reason I liked Barber's book better, for her close appraisal of Tarim fabrics and then to speak of how they might have been made. One feature of the mummies was the women with "witch" hats. The authors simply say the real witch's hat was Puritan dress from the 17th century and then blithely go on. Now somehow I believed the Puritans were Christians not pagans, but maybe I'm wrong.

Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ? Oui Non (Signaler ce commentaire)

Partagez votre opinion avec les autres clients: Cr�er votre propre commentaire

› Lire les 9 commentaires des internautes

Commentaires client les plus r�cents

4.0�toiles sur 5 Dull treatment of a fascinating topic.
I don't consider myself a fan of "popular" treatments of specialized subject matter, but I couldn't help wishing the authors had even just a hint of a flair for... Read more

Publi� le F�v 15 2002 par Jacques Talbot

5.0�toiles sur 5 Fascinating book on an intriguing archaeological mystery
"The Tarim Mummies" weaves field data, historical background, scholarship, and informed speculation into probably the best account of this subject yet published. Read more

Publi� le Sep 19 2000 par JLP

5.0�toiles sur 5 Impressive volume
I've had a life long interest in ancient history and have studied it to the MA level. In my exposure to the process of learning the subject, it often seemed to me that somehow... Read more

Publi� le Ao� 20 2000 par Atheen M. Wilson

5.0�toiles sur 5 Wonderful
Mair and Mallory did an excellent job. They not only cover the mummies and the archaeological finds, they also provide lots of historical background and context, which is... Read more

Publi� le Ao� 7 2000 par Jonathan Hendry