|
3.0étoiles sur 5
not too bad..., Jui 17 2004
...but not as good as the movie.I feel bad saying that, since the movie CAME from the book; it's just that the movie has more twists and more depth of character development -- particularly at the end. Brother Leon, for example, comes across as much more wicked in the film, and the supporting cast is more sharply drawn. I also felt the book suffered from the use of omniscient narrator technique. It seemed to reduce the suspense and focus. Also, such scenes as the evil gang of little kids are much more effective visually than they are in print. One of the reasons, I suppose, that I found the movie so creepy and disturbing was because there was this desolated, lonely atmosphere to everything, implying, in a way, that the schoolboys were actors of mythic stature at the beginning of an empty world. Nothing but the Brothers and them. I think this is due, however, to the movie's being brought off on a shoestring budget; I'm not sure the director intended it this way. Whatever the case may be, this thing -- this central excellence of the film, in my view -- is totally missing from the book. I think the author was going for a kind of William Golding-type idea, but I don't think he succeeds anywhere near as that other author. He depicts evil, sure enough, but it just doesn't seem to have enough grip or intensity to be compelling. However, on balance, a worthwhile read. Who can't identify with the degrading chocolate sales that every American school -- both public and private -- "invite" their students to participate in? More development of the reader's sympathy for Jerry, the central character, would certainly have helped.
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles
Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ?
|
|
|
|