Commentaires client les plus utiles
|
|
4.0étoiles sur 5
Good science fiction, Mai 10 2004
The acceptance of different sexualities in future societies has long been a staple of science fiction. To downgrade this book on the basis that it deals in part with homosexuality does it a disservice. If you don't like HOW it deals with the issue (meaning the writing is awkward, belabored, etc.,), that's one thing. To object because it DOES deal with it is a completely different situation. This book deals with the issue of who you are, both genetically and sociologically. Who you are depends so much on your experiences in life, the people who had an effect on you as you grew, your inborn personality, and the way you interact with the world and the way the world interacts with you. So yes, homosexuality is an issue in this book, but as part of a larger picture: if in the future, test-tube babies and genetic engineering become the norm, how will that affect our families? How will it affect our concepts of ourselves? But the issue of family is central: If a parent can't or doesn't provide the love and nuturing we need, it's vital to find a loving and supportive adult figure who can. If in this case, that happens to be Joss's mother's same-sex partner, so be it.
That issue aside, I found this a very good read. The characters were distinct and interesting. The situations were intriguing. It's not new for a science fiction novel to explore first contact with alien species, but Goodman's aliens have depth and texture, and the difference and similarities between the species are explored sensitively. I found the relationship between Joss and Mavkel a high point in the book. I loved Joss's rebellious, independent character, and I wanted to know more about her walk on the shady side. Between the characterizations and the well-developed sense of time and place, let alone suspense, the book definitely kept me reading. (...) The book ends too quickly and conveniently. I saw most of the ending coming, and I found it a little obvious. I'll be recommending this book to readers, but it isn't quite at the top of my list.
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles
Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ?
 
|
|
|
|
|
|
1.0étoiles sur 5
A few complaints, Fév 8 2004
The one annoying and aggravating aspect of this book was the sheer fact of how many times the author felt possesed to push her ideas of homosexuailty on the readers. For one instance, the main character Joss's mother, Ingrid has a girlfriend, and the girlfriend was a steady role model (father figure) in the girls life and it was incrediably sad for Joss when Ingrid and the woman broke up. Ingrid asseses that it was infact the employers of the girlfriend that told her that she needed to find a male because she was essentially scaring off conservative costumers. So saying that due to the conservative costumers, this great gay influence in the characters life was severed. Another instance Joss randomly goes into this quilt and AIDS museum where loved ones of aids victims had quilted in memory blocks, but a large section of the quilt had been deliberatory burnt by people opposed to the 1987 homosexual marriage law. Again making out people who disagree with homosexuality to be bigoted and uncaring. One other time Joss tells Mavkal that not only men and women can be together, but men and men and women and women, so it didnt matter which personal pronoun he decided to call himself. One other problem I had with the reading of this novel, while it is meant for teenagers, the language is juvinile and the main character, though 18 sounds immature and not that much departed from a sterotypical rebel. A good note to the book is the idea of the nature of the aliens, and the interactions between mavkal and Joss were entertaining.I want to read about aliens and time travel, not having some author push her politicized sexual ideals onto me mupltiple times when im trying to read. For a good sci-fi, I suggest Enders Game.
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles
Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ?
|
|
|
|
|
|
4.0étoiles sur 5
Singing The Dogstar Blues, Fév 3 2004
Par Un client
Aliens. Aliens from a distant planet have landed on the Earth. The landing was expected and anticipated. Joss Aarrenson attends an academy so she can learn how to time jump (time travel) into the history or future. The aliens that land on the Earth are called Chorians. Joss is chosen to partner up with a visiting alien who wants to learn how to time jump. Mavkel was his name, Mav for short. Mav soon becomes closer to Joss, and after a little getting used to, Joss is treating Mav like a family member. Things soon get harder and harder for Joss and Mav, and Mav is falling further into depression and closer to death. Refmol, the chorian chanter, finds that Mav must be joined telepathically with another being if he is to stay alive. Joss is the only thing, and in this case hope, for Mav. She must find her father if she is to join with Mav, but she's been trying for as long as she can remember. Why Joss? Why Mav?
This story is told in a mysterious and futuristic way that is sure to make you want to keep reading until the end. It is hilarious in parts, and always leaves a question pounding in your head that you won't find out until you're finished with the book. A thrilling and entertaining story!
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles
Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Commentaires client les plus récents
|
