Most helpful customer reviews
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
My succinct review, Jun 19 2001
I will endeavor to keep this review as brief as possible:I have not read that many books, to be honest with you; but Ondaatje's "The English Patient" is the most enjoyable of all the ones that I have read. Ondaatje's style is unique and one can see that this is a poet at work; the breadth of his vocabulary is immense and his extravagant use of poetic devices make the book a work of art. Suffice it to say that I have never read a novel which incorporates so much of the literary scope into one product: this is not just a novel; it's poetry and art as well. The only thing I did not like about this book is that, at times it can go off topic a bit and become quite drab- but this is the exception rather than the rule, and the novel as a whole is very enjoyable.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Stunning certainly, but his best??, Feb 3 2001
I love Ondaatje's work, but there is none better than 'In the skin of a lion', there is no book more deserving of any award, including this one. I have began and put down this book so frequently it is already dog-eared from my constant indecision. I think I feared that perhaps I would be disapppointed. I adore both'In the Skin of a Lion' and 'Anil's Ghost' (to an extent) and I thought the film was amazingly beautiful. I must admit, I was slightly disappointed, but certainly, I could never regret finally reading the piece. There is a beauty captured many books, and no author captures the beauty of words and creates a more stunning and remembered image than Ondaatje. I hate history books. Certainly, I see the importance of recording history, but I am far from a budding historian. This book has a substantial portion devoted to the events surrounding the second world war. I also hate sand and probably would despise deserts should I one day find the need to venture into one. This book has a substantial portion devoted to the desert. So we began on bad terms. But there is more to this novel than sand and history; there is striking romanticism on several levels, wonderfully crafted descriptions and stunningly vivid characters. There is immense heartbreak and a fine weave of several sub stories. It is deep rich and vivid and worth reading. Particularly if you like sand, history and explosives. (Thankfully he hit a note with me there.) 'In the Skin of a lion' seems that tiny bit better, but I would have no hestitations in reccommending either, or any, of Ondaatje's work.
|
|
|
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Brilliant, Brilliant, May 19 2002
Ondaatje is a superb writer. The English Patient is a brilliant book. Ondaatje's genius is to reveal characters as people are revealed in life - not in linear chronological narratives, but in glimpes, flashes of lightning, disconnected anecdotes. Sometimes contradictory, always fascinating. The book takes the shape of these disparate images and recollections slowly coalescing to form four protagonists: Hana the Canadian nurse, Almasy the English Patient, Caravaggio the thief, and Kip the Sikh deminer. They are isolated from the world in a postwar Italian villa, each with subtle motives defined by Ondaatje's profound attention to detail. The prose is evocative, like Almasy's comment on Kipling: to be read slowly and then reread. Images and scenes slowly take shape like a jigsaw puzzle. It is not until the final few pages that we finally learn what compels Hana to tend so devotedly to the mortally-burned English Patient, it is not until the final pages that Kip reviews his dedication to the British war cause. The characters' evolutions come slowly and naturally as Almasy's stories of the desert catalyze the entire book. The movie is not this book. Read the book - it's brilliant.
|
|
|
Most recent customer reviews
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
Complicated, dense, poetic, erotic, wow, wow, wow!
Don't miss this - and don't miss the movie, either. The English Patient is a completely enthralling novel of war, honor, romance, and courage.
Read more
Published on Jun 13 2003 by Peggy Vincent
|
|