Commentaires client les plus utiles
|
|
2.0étoiles sur 5
The Bore, Jui 16 2004
Lady Georgiana Halley was once seduced and ruined by Viscount Dare because of a wager that he could charm her out of both a kiss and a stocking. Heartbroken after finding out about the wager, she and Lord Dare have been in a fierce battle (fought quietly in the ballrooms of London) for six years. When Dare seems to be seriously courting another woman, Georgiana decides to intercede to "teach him a lesson" so that he doesn't hurt this woman as he hurt her.Viscount Dare inherited a financial mess when his father died four years before, so for the sake of the aunts and brothers he loves he's decided to marry rich to repair the family fortunes. He's just begun to court a rich young woman when Georgiana steals his attention, placing herself firmly back into his life by moving in with him under the guise of playing companion to his elderly aunts. Dare never ruined Georgiana as he could have, keeping the stocking for himself and losing the wager. (Something Georgiana seems to lack the intelligence to realize.) He enjoyed seducing her, and even underneath their thinly veiled war of words (and sometimes fans) he still feels a small attraction and if she's willing, he'll pick things up where they left off six years ago. With a bevy of secondary characters (useless except for the fact that they're obvious advertisements for future books), "The Rake" is mostly Georgiana's attempt to teach Dare a lesson. The first 100 pages were difficult for me to get through, only my determination not to have wasted $6 kept me going. After the first bit, the reading became easier, mainly because the comedy-type situations had thinned out and there was some real emotion coming through. At the end, though, one scene with stupid actions on the part of both the hero and heroine left me cold. I don't like the fact that Dare seduced Georgiana and never offered to marry her, as a man's honor at that time could be measured by that very action; it's also made clear that Dare would have no interest in Georgiana if she didn't have money, and that fact is played off as something we simply ought to be grateful for. I'm thrown off later when Dare seems likeable in other ways after his behavior to both Georgiana and the other woman he's courting. It just doesn't seem consistent with his character that he could have been so totally careless in his actions. Toward the middle of the book, I don't really believe that he's capable of the behavior he's guilty of; I think bad characterization is to blame. Georgiana is a moron. There really isn't much more to say. I think she was silly for being so easily seduced all of those years ago, and her ideas for revenge are totally irrational. At the moment I'm at a loss to name one likeable thing about her. "The Rake" is more a comedy of manners type Regency than a true historical romance (except maybe for the love scenes). Between the lousy characterization and the slight change in the tone of the book, I find it hard to believe that the fans of either type of book would be truly happy with it as a whole. "The Rake" gets two stars from me only because I could stand to finish it--my one star ratings are reserved for books I can't get through.
|
|
|
4.0étoiles sur 5
Ultimately, a satisfying read..., Jui 6 2004
I'll admit, at first I found it hard to warm up to this book. Although I liked the plot, upon starting the book, I found there were a few aspects I just couldn't seem to accept. One aspect in particular lessened my enjoyment. However, once I moved past said obstacle, I was able to appreciate this book for the witty, enjoyable read it turned out to be. The lead characters were likable and amusing from the very start- Georgiana was strong and determined, yet endearing; Dare was sweet in his pursuit to win Georgiana. The supporting characters were just as charming, making the book all the more enjoyable; Dare's brothers were individually imperfect and the aunties were adorable. Lucinda and Evelyn were promising as entertaining heroines in their own stories. Although I was a little slow in warming up to this book, I genuinely like Suzanne Enoch's style in writing, as I very much enjoyed both of her novellas in the "Lady Whistledown" anthologies. I look forward to reading the following two books in the "Lessons in Love" series.
|
|
|
2.0étoiles sur 5
Disappointing story relies on annoying plot devices, Mai 13 2004
Several years ago, Lady Georgiana Halley had been smitten with the handsome rake, Viscount Dare. In fact, he had charmed her to the point she lost her virginity to him. But what she found out afterward was humiliating. Lord Dare had made a wager with some gentlemen that he could bed Georgiana. She has never forgiven him for treating her in such a cold and calculating manner. Now he's seriously courting another young miss, and Georgiana hatches a plan to give Dare his comeuppance, and insure he proposes to the young lady. She manages to get herself invited to stay with him and his family, all the while using every feminine wile she possesses to make Dare fall in love with her. Then she plans to discard him just as he did her. The only hitch is, she didn't count on the intensity of her feelings for him, and he's never gotten her out of his system. This was my first book to read by this author, and apparently this wasn't a good choice for me to begin with. It started out being cute and funny with the antagonistic relationship between Dare and Georgiana, but the story deteriorated as I read on. It became juvenile in nature, and just too corny to be believable. Plus, I really dislike the big misunderstanding and revenge plot devices. Unfortunately, this book contained both. In fact, I quit reading it and just skimmed through the rest. The main characters were one-dimensional and lacked real emotional depth. I've read some of the other reviews that say this author has much better work out there, so I will probably try another by her. But I don't recommend reading this, especially if you've not read Ms. Enoch before.
|
|
|
Commentaires client les plus récents
|