|
|
1 internautes sur 1 ont trouvé ce commentaire utile :
4.0étoiles sur 5
Taxidermy meets Behind the Attic Wall meets Teddy., Mars 24 2001
"Tideland," Mitch Cullin's third novel, is at once similar and different than his first two novels, "Whompyjawed" & "Branches." First, the background takes place in the vast wilds of West Texas - loosely connected to the two prior novels. (In Whompjawed, Sherriff Branches - the narrative voice in Branches - has a cameo appearance. And, completing the circle, in Tideland there is a mention of Willy Keeler, star football player in Whompyjawed. - So, we can assume Tideland takes place in the same region as the first two...) Cullin, using the eyes of Tideland's narrator Jeliza Rose, again shows his gift for capturing surrounding. The look through a small girl's imaginative world born amongst the surrounding Johnsongrass, the mesquite, fireflies, etc. It takes on a magical quality, without being overly sentimental. It reminded me of a juvenile book I read years ago, "Behind the Attic Wall" by Sylvia Cassedy. Except I felt that a large portion of the middle section of Tideland could have been eliminated with. Some might appreciate the "real time" aspect of it, but I have to say it became an annoyance the way it began to loop, day to day. When Jeliza Rose finally meets the odd duo of Dell and Dickens, it is a sigh of relief. In Tideland, Cullin seems to extemporize many of the odd details amongst its pages. Like Jeliza's father's obsession with Denmark, bog men, his rockabilly past, onto the imaginative worlds of Jeliza and Dickens', etc. Most of these details seem to have no purpose other than being creative. But I, personally, appreciated it, and also encourage Cullin to cut loose more in the future. Which leads to a criticism of Tideland. Throughout much of the novel Jeliza's voice bounces around from extremely naïve to Salinger's Teddy gifted, making connections and observations most adults may pass over. In Whompyjawed, Cullin's sense of tact, control, and believability in the narrator's voice is impeccable. As is Branches, for that matter. But in Tideland, I got the definite sense that Cullin wanted to breakout and away from the boundaries of Jeliza's voice. And though Jeliza often mimicked things heard or learned from her father/mother, there's a different feeling that Cullin interjected himself, his creative observations in place of the limited capacities of Jeliza's. And though saying what I have, Tideland is darkly funny, creative, and an interesting read. Its plots (once into gear) twist into unexpected places of the heart and imagination at the drop of a hat. And even though I do not recommend Tideland as highly as his first two efforts, Cullin is a great talent to be reckoned with. Watch out.
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles
Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ?
|
|
|
|