Most helpful customer reviews
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The best Vonnegut novel I have read, Jul 17 2004
This is my fifth Vonnegut novel (I have already read Player Piano, Cat's Cradle, Slaughterhouse-Five, and Breakfast of Champions) and I can say with confidence that The Sirens of Titan is the best in this group. It is neat to see Vonnegut's novels evolve over time: Player Piano, while still a masterpiece, is a very conventional novel without a lot of the craziness that is so evident in his later novels. Breakfast of Champions is the most unconventional novel I have ever read, its like the two books were written by two totally different authors. The Sirens of Titan, on the other hand, is somewhere in the middle. There is a clear plot in the story, much like Player Piano, but it is not as structured as the former. We begin to see the early beginnings of what would later become one of Vonnegut's trademarks: unrelenting sarcasm and irony. What makes The Sirens of Titan my favorite Vonnegut novel? Everything comes together at the very end. Throughout the novel, there is a clear question looming over the reader and the characters in the book: the purpose of human life. Vonnegut answers this question (or Malachi Constant, rather) in the last few pages of the story, and it is absolutely brilliant. The fact that the author even dared to ask such a question and then answer it, is extraordinary.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
It has its moments, Sep 11 2008
I liked the first few sentences and that's why I bought it. I imagined it would be a reflective read.
The book is very imaginative and at times quite complex in the range of psychological, theological, and political undertones. The author has a caustic sense of humour, the sarcasm is hillarious but at times disturbing. I was in particular moved by the part that describes the violent destruction of the Martian army, which turned out to be ordinary people, including women and children.
The author makes a valid point about the stance we take towards our accomplishments and self-worth, and things we attribute to ourselves such as the will of god and luck. For a related view, read Black Swan by Taleb, as well as other work discussing the role of chance in human life and our perception of chance.
By the end of the book, the author started rambling. It felt as if he was rushing to finish it and there wasn't much left to say. I must admit, I skimmed the last chapter or two. The imaginativeness started to get a bit annoying and repetitive. If you are a fan of Brecht's plays, you may enjoy this style.
I definitely feel I took a lot from this book and enjoyed reading it, but the last 25% put a dent in my experience.
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
Titanic, Sep 18 2006
I've read all of Vonnegut's novels and I think they are best categorized under three different kinds. There is the social-satirical like mother night and hocus pocus, boderline science fiction like player piano, and, my favorite, the schizophrenic, science fiction, social-satire all rolled into one like Slaughterhouse-five and Sirens of Titan. Though Sirens of Titan is not as good as Slaughterhouse, it is a great, great book. Would also recommend the Vonnegut-like `Katzenjammer' by Jackson McCrae for equally good fun.
|
|
|
Most recent customer reviews
|