|
|
2.0 out of 5 stars
Low-impact horror, Mar 3 2005
This edition of Dark Universe, along with the concurrently released Nightworlds, published by Dorchester Publishing under the Leisure label in paperback, contain all forty-one stories found in the 2001 edition of Dark Universe published by Stealth Press. If you are a fan, or curious to delve into Nolan's horror short fiction (spanning five decades), the two paperbacks represent a substantial money saver, since the Stealth Press edition sold for about thirty dollars in hardcover.However, while the Stealth Press edition arranged the stories chronologically by year, earliest to latest, the two Dorchester releases abandon this approach in favour of mixing the order. While each story is preceded by an introduction by the author, reading the book from start to finish offers only a jumbled sense of how Nolan's style has developed over the years. Being new to Nolan's writing, I took a chance and bought both Leisure releases, and after having read Dark Universe and the first few stories in Nightworlds, I have to say I'm disappointed and feel a bit duped by marketing tactics. Nolan's abilities as a horror writer seem secondary to his abilities as a writer of science fiction, the genre on which he established his reputation. Indeed, Dark Universe contains one piece of science/speculative fiction (And Miles to Go Before I Sleep) which doesn't count as horror at all. All in all, I have to say I find Nolan's horror writing to be simplistic, as though aimed at a juvenile reading level. Situations and plots lack substance, and atmosphere and tone are too weak to create a very effective sense of fear or dread. Characters are shallow and one-dimensional, and his dialogue is horrible - relying on hackneyed phraseology such as "the hell you say" as an expression of dismay. Don't be fooled by the cover quotes that make Nolan sound like one of the greatest horror writers. When I sat down to read him, I was expecting a full course dinner, but instead I got popcorn. For truly effective, disturbing horror, try reading Ramsey Campbell.
|