Commentaires client les plus utiles
|
|
5.0étoiles sur 5
Putting the pieces in place for the climax, Mai 12 2004
And so with "Treasure Hunters," we take the final step before the end of the "Bone" series. In this, the eighth of nine volumes, we see a return to the humor that has run through much of the series ("Ghost Circles" was grim indeed)."Bone" is an huge story about three "bone creatures" and their adventures in a quaint valley of peasants, hidden princesses, dragons and creatures. Like a dark cloud looming over it all is the menace of a great evil intent on taking over the world. The series starts off lighthearted, but grows to become an epic story rooted in fantasy, without the Tolkienesque elves and dwarves. This installment bring us into a city rather than the valley that has been at the center of the series. The forward progression for the grand tale is small indeed here. Instead, Smith begins to position all of the pieces of the puzzle for the final climax, while unexpectedly adding a few new pieces - a religious tyrant and an underground rebellion - to make the climax all that much more frantic. Most of the action in "Treasure Hunters" takes place in the city. Few side plots or diversions outside of the city show up. The result is one of the faster reads of the "Bone" series.
This is the kind of comic tale that will appeal to a wide demographic. Smith combines the classic storytelling perfected by the likes of Carl Barks (Donald Duck, Uncle Scrooge) and Bill Watterson (Calvin & Hobbes) - characters with outrageous and expressive faces and gestures - with the epic plotting of a sweeping fairy tale. "Bone" manages to balance the two well enough to be something fans of both Donald Duck and Frodo Baggins can enjoy. There is no doubt people will still be reading "Bone" 50 years from now. Broad and epic in scope yet personal and quaint, this is a charming story in every way that will surely outlast most other comic works on the shelf.
|
|
|
4.0étoiles sur 5
Less than expected, Oct. 23 2003
This is the eighth installment of the Bone series. It continues to follow the adventures of the Bones and Thorn. The big change in this story is that it moves from the outdoors to the city. Nearly all of the action takes place in the city of Atheia. Thorn comes closer to understanding her role in the world.Generally speaking, I love the Bone series, and I have rated all of the previous books with five stars. However there are some weak points in this book which prevent me from giving it five stars. One point is that the shift from the outdoors to the city gives this book a rather cramped feel. I believe that Jeff Smith has a certain talent for drawing outdoor scenes, and that talent doesn't seem to be in use in this book. Another point is that a lot of new characters are introduced, which takes away page space from the characters we already know and love, and what is worse, the new characters are not in the least bit interesting. They are all stock types. Also I cringed to see the appearance of dwarfs and gnomes in the city. One of the points I liked about the Bone series is the freedom it had from the typical swords and sorcery fantasy, but I guess he ran out of ideas. Don't get me wrong. It's not a bad book. It's just not as good as the others. Of course if you're following the Bone story, you have to get this. Let's just hope that Smith regains his touch in the next book. Oh, and no more gnomes please.
|
|
|
3.0étoiles sur 5
Good, but..., Aoû 25 2003
I love Bone, and I would unhesitatingly give every collection up to this one five stars. This was the first volume that let me down. Jeff Smith had previously concentrated on a handful of very well-developed, very likable, surprisingly complicated characters. In this volume, he expands the cast by about twofold, and most of the new characters are grotesques who aren't particularly engaging. Their most interesting characteristics are their funny-looking eyebrows/nose rings/beards/moustaches/teeth. The city of Atheiea is filled with hundreds of misshapen freaks who don't serve much purpose, and reminded me of Jabba the Hutt's palace. If the dark and intense "Ghost Circles" was the "Empire Strikes Back" of the series, "Treasure Hunters" is the "Return of the Jedi". And "Return of the Jedi" was awful. I hope that Jeff Smith will be able to handle all the new plot lines and characters he's introduced here. Given that he's Jeff Smith, he just might do so masterfully, but for the first time in this series, I'm doubtful.
|
|
|
Commentaires client les plus récents
|
