Most helpful customer reviews
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
Luminous, Dec 29 2003
Yes, luminous is the word that describes Lipatti's recording of the Fourteen Waltzes best: "bright or shining, especially in the dark."I bought this CD fourteen years ago, and since then I have not found an interpretation that even comes close to Lipatti's. His recording of Chopin's waltzes is worlds apart from those of all other pianists. No one else captured the terrifying and exhilarating coexistence of darkness and light in these ostensibly innocent pieces as convincingly as Lipatti. Waltzes are dances of joy, very easy to learn and perform. Once very popular among all classes, their emotional range covered everything from the exuberant to the sentimental. Today, they have a reputation for either rustic fun or plain kitsch. What Lipatti found in Chopin's waltzes goes far beyond the conventional. Played by him, these dances are testament to the pleasure to live in the face of suffering. Lipatti is the one pianist who can genuinely express both the joy of living and the awareness of mortality in as simple a piece of music as a waltz. Playful, wise, sublime. Luminous. Listen!
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
Absolute Perfection, Jun 23 2003
By A Customer
These works are perhaps as difficult to play as Mozart because they require everything at once: instinct, sense of form, clarity, rigor, and natural phrasing. I am afraid other pianists can pretty much try niceties, smart secondary voices (Katsaris, Samson-Francois), flexible rythms that are quite effective in conveying the dance spirit of these works (Bunin) or remain safely in the artificial world of tricks and problem-solving (Barenboim playing a couple of them in concert or, horribly flat-footed, the otherwise excellent JB Pommier), but only one of them goes to the heart of this music and conveys what is essential about it with completely natural phrasing that makes it sing with dignity, beauty, clarity and absolute (and I mean absolute) digital perfection and this is Lipatti. If you get the CD with the Barcarolle, it is also the most impressive I know, alongside Moravec's.
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
helpful consideration, Nov 25 2002
By A Customer
I'd just like to comment on the Rubenstein issue: As a pianist, I'm aware of the vast differences of opinion regarding interpretations. In my humble opinion, certain pianists do have certain 'sounds', certain ways of interpreting and expressing, and this comes through in recording. Rubenstein has a certain sound, -- identifiable on any recording, really, -- and whether you think his is the best or not, it is certainly legitimate. I find that I enjoy his recordings for a number of reasons, especially for educational and comparative listening. However, I find that other pianists produce more enjoyable listening. And this is only my personal opinion. To me, Rubenstein does not play with the abandon of spirit that I appreciate in some other pianists, and so I prefer this recording to his for pure enjoyment. Each person must make her/his own choice, and then sit back and love your music!
|
|
|
Most recent customer reviews
|