|
5.0étoiles sur 5
I wish I could give this recording a fifteen star rating!, Jui 15 2004
Par Un client
First of all, I must state that I have loved this recording for three plus decades. I have LP copies of it on MGM, Heliodor, and DGG pressings. But I am one who has been waiting for years to find it released on CD. When the CD set finally came out, I was beside myself with joy.This is the Baby Doe to have. Someone mentioned the 1996 CD recording of Baby Doe, which was recorded in the Central City Opera House. That's a very good recording. The entire cast is/are wonderful. And that recording includes a few bars(in the first act) which are cut from the Sills Baby Doe. But as fine as the 1996 recording is; it would be impossible to top or even match Cassel, Sills, and Bible as the Tabor love triangle. I attended one of the 1996 Central City Opera Baby Doe performances. I was elated to see/hear the opera performed in that glorious old house. But I have to admit that the acoustic ambiance of the Central City Opera House was a bit tubby and dry (acoustically). The tubby and dry ambiance of the 1996 Baby Doe recording is one of the reasons I prefer the Sills recording. Anyway. I have made two pilgrimages to Leadville. The Tabor Grand Opera House (which is in desperate need of funds for restoration) is still standing and in business. The Clarendon Hotel (which was adjacent to the Tabor Grand) was torn down decades ago (although evidence of the Tabor cat walk from the Tabor Grand to the Clarendon is still extant). Both times I visited Leadville, standing on the stage of the Tabor Grand left me speechless. But my two visits to Baby Doe's cabin at the Matchless Mine devastated me. Both times I stood in the "cold and narrow house" in which Baby Doe died so emotionally overwhelmed me that I had to step outside. I didn't want the rest of the tourees to see me weeping. I couldn't help reacting that way. As I stood in Baby's cabin, her final aria , "Always Through the Changing" (as sung by Sills) kept running through my mind. For those who have not heard this Opera (especially the Sills recording) you all really must listen to it. It's one of the few truly great American Operas. Moore's score is glorious. The Latouche libretto is outstanding. And the story of Baby Doe (upon which the opera is based) is well represented (with a few dramatic alterations) in the opera.
|