Commentaires client les plus utiles
|
|
4.0étoiles sur 5
Read this before you buy!! This is the ORIGINAL Captain Britain, Janv. 19 2010
As i was trolling through here i noticed this book, and hence the reviews. The reviews are why i am writing and reviewing myself. The reviews I have seen for this book here are actually NOT for this book. Everyone seems to be mixing it with another collection that is out there of Alan Moore and Alan Davis' run on the Captain Britain title. This, in fact, predates Moore and Davis' run and is the original weekly series, collecting Captain Britain Weekly issues 1-23. Written by Chris Claremont (and then by Gary Freidrich) with spectacular art by the fantastic Herb Trimpe.
I'm not sure why everyone has thought this to be a Moore collection. It says right at the top that it's Claremont.
As for the quality of the book, that is subjective. I really enjoy it. Part of that is because it's a nostalia thing and it's great art. It certainly isn't Claremont's best. His run on Cap is notorious for annoying actual Brits with it's cliches and 'incorrect Britishness'. But it was early on for Marvel UK and they were just getting their feet wet. This is pre Otherworld, Excalibur, Roma, Betsy having any powers. Its a very different storyline than what Moore morphed it into years later. It's Cap in his old, original suit, is much more mystic based and has simple, short storylines.
Ok so that's it. Just wanted to clear that up.
Those folks may be talking about the Captain Britain Omnibus. That's Moore and Davis and is highly recommended.
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles
Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ?
 
|
|
|
|
|
|
5.0étoiles sur 5
Excellent early work from Alan Moore & Alan Davis, Oct. 24 2003
I have to get this out of the way first: this book is a must-have for any fans of Alan Moore's work on Miracleman! I was unaware of his work on this Marvel UK title until a recent browse through a local comic shop. It might be a tad hard to come by, but it can still be found!Collecting a classic and definitive run from the very early '80s, CAPTAIN BRITAIN features some outstanding writing and artwork. It's fascinating to see Moore and Davis in the very early phases of their careers. You can feel the presence of the great works to come from both highly-regarded creators. Moore's writing gives many hints of the more well-known adult-themes to come from him in the mid- to late '80s. Davis' style, while a bit rough at first, quickly develops as he gains more confidence with the characters (in fact, Moore spends almost the entire introduction praising Davis' work, and rightly so). Be warned that the beginning of this book is not actually the beginning of the storyline, but it suffices. You are dropped into the middle of an ongoing story that the 2 inherited at the last minute. Within that last minute, however, a good chunk of the UK's superheroes are killed by The Fury, including Miracleman AND the title character! Using a format that will be familiar to readers of Moore's Swamp Thing, the Captain is resurrected and redefined, leading to a rematch that doesn't disappoint. I am so happy to have found this treasure. I'm hoping that we will see more collections from Marvel UK in the future.
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles
Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ?
|
|
|
|
|
|
5.0étoiles sur 5
Classic Stuff!, Nov. 21 2002
As Author Alan Moore states in his introduction, the stories in this book are from VERY early on in the careers of himself and Artist Alan Davis, but they hold up remarkably well. The basic story will be familiar to longtime comic fans: Hero is thrown into an alternate reality, must face a megomaniacal madman, etc.; What's so cool about Captain Britain is that this story was published over TWENTY YEARS AGO, so all of the similar stories we're more familiar with (Crisis on Infinite Earths, X-Men's Days of Future Past, even Moore's & Davis'own Miracleman)had their genesis here. The book gets off to a head-scratching start; We're thrown into the closing chapters of a long-running story-arc that Moore & Davis had the misfortune of inheriting, but they do an amazing job of not only making the complex story and characters accessible, but actually making them interesting. Moore starts by killing Captain Britain, and rebuilding him from the ground up, as he would later do with DC's Swamp Thing. By the third or fourth chapter, Moore & Davis have hit their stride, and are beginning to impart their own voices on the book. Part of the fun is seeing how fast Moore and Davis grow as creators; Moore learns that sometimes silence can be just as powerful as words, and Davis becomes a confident, masterful storyteller in his own right. By the time I finished the book, I felt like I had just discovered a long-hidden masterpiece. I don't know if this is the ENTIRE Moore/Davis Captain Britain run, but if it isn't, I hope Marvel gets the rest into print again FAST. Fans of Marvel's Excalibur series will also be interested to know that this book contains the first appearance of Meggan, The Captain's future love interest. There's also a cameo appearance by the aforementioned Miracleman. While not Moore's best work, it's still head-and-shoulders above 90% of the material out there. Give it a try!
Aidez d'autres clients à trouver les commentaires les plus utiles
Ce commentaire vous a-t-il été utile ?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Commentaires client les plus récents
|
