Profile for I. Sherman > Reviews

Personal Profile

Content by I. Sherman
Top Reviewer Ranking: 512,950
Helpful Votes: 5

Guidelines: Learn more about the ins and outs of Amazon Communities.

Reviews Written by
I. Sherman (NY)
(REAL NAME)   

Page: 1
pixel
March of the Wooden Soldiers [Import]
March of the Wooden Soldiers [Import]
DVD ~ Frank Austin
Offered by PaperbackshopCA
Price: CDN$ 10.19
11 used & new from CDN$ 10.17

5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Legend edition wins hands down, Nov. 21 2006
March of the Wooden Soldiers has always been a holiday favorite of mine and thus I was saddened when the local NY stations stopped featuring the film on Thanksgiving. Interested in obtaining the best available version of the film, I first purchased the recommended Goodtimes and Passport reissues of the film. A few days later I came upon the most recently released Legend edition. On Sunday I compared the three DVDs.

No question, while I at one time might have agreed with earlier reviews claiming the Passport B&W version as the most accurate representation of the film, and the Goodtimes version as the best of the color incarnations, they both have now been blown out of the water with this latest Legend package. First, the Legend package includes both restored B&W and colorized versions of the film. In both cases the transfers are crisper, brighter, present higher detail resolution and are cleaner overall. In B&W the detail of Barnaby's coat, Stannie's legging patches and all graphics have been enhanced. The compromise might be the bit of edginess that goes along with such detail enhancement but overall its a small price to pay. As for the colorization, the detail resolution will have you marveling at a nuance in new color detail not even remotely evident in the Goodtimes edition. Second, well a better deal is just a better deal!

In short, Legend lives up to its name here. Anyone interested in slightly used Goodtimes and Passport DVDs? Please?

Page: 1