Profile for Sue Hirst > Reviews

Personal Profile

Content by Sue Hirst
Top Reviewer Ranking: 4,049
Helpful Votes: 32

Guidelines: Learn more about the ins and outs of Amazon Communities.

Reviews Written by
Sue Hirst (Canada)

Page: 1 | 2 | 3
pixel
Mercy of St. Jude
Mercy of St. Jude
by Wilhemina Fitzpatrick
Edition: Paperback
Price: CDN$ 14.56
4 used & new from CDN$ 7.69

5.0 out of 5 stars A wonderful sense of place, May 22 2012
This review is from: Mercy of St. Jude (Paperback)
I just recently re-read this book and remembered how much I love it! It made me want to visit Newfoundland and explore the close-knit communities there which are so well depicted in this novel.
This is truly a novel with a secret at the core...and uncovering this secret pulls the reader through the story at breakneck pace on a first reading. It was delightful to go back a second time and discover the nuances of the complex characters on a second reading.
For me, a significant part of the appeal of this novel is it's confident sense of place. Fitzpatrick obviously has a close connection to Newfoundland. Having spent two days of a long weekend immersed in her book, I too feel I have begun to
know Newfoundland.

A Raw Mix of Carelessness and Longing
A Raw Mix of Carelessness and Longing
by Cecelia Frey
Edition: Paperback
Price: CDN$ 14.56
18 used & new from CDN$ 8.05

5.0 out of 5 stars A road trip of a read, April 7 2009
I love road trips. The pavement unwinding beneath the car wheels, unknown towns scrolling past the windows, great music on the radio and someone interesting in the passenger seat to talk to.

"A Raw Mix of Carelessness and Longing" was a road trip of a read - like taking a long journey with an new acquaintance, one you don't know well but are predisposed to like.

It is a very Canadian book with its sparse understated writing, subtle but incredibly well observed humour, and fascinating characters that stay with you long after you've slammed the car door, hustled your backpack onto your shoulders and waved goodbye to your travelling companions.

Cecelia Frey tells the story of Lilah Cellini and Jamey Popolowski - the free-spirited musician Lilah has been in love with all her life. Frey has a keen sense of story and a wonderful ear for dialogue (I could listen to Lilah for thousand's of kilometres.)
Frey deftly weaves the events of Lilah's unpredictable life with those of the folk she leaves behind in her hometown and the people she meets on the road when she follows Jamey as he chases his dream of making it big in music.
As the two young people cross Canada with Jamey's band, Lilah discovers that the choices which must be made in life are never easy. She find's that following someone else's dream can come at significant cost to oneself. As Lilah struggles with the alternatives presented to her she finds an unexpected ally in the enigmatic Zeke (the band's manager) who ultimately helps her find her own voice (both literally and figuratively). Although the voice of the story is Lilah's, Jamie's voice is heard in the lyrics of his songs which adds an additional layer to the novel.
This is a spellbinding tale. It seems so simply conceived when you first open the pages (like turning the key in the ignition) but, as with all long road trips, there are unexpected twist and turns on the journey that make it an absorbing read.

Highly recommended.

Icefields
Icefields
by Thomas Wharton
Edition: Paperback
Price: CDN$ 16.24
38 used & new from CDN$ 0.01

4.0 out of 5 stars A book like a dream or a reverie, April 7 2009
This review is from: Icefields (Paperback)
This is a book I have read more than once. It's not a book you read for the plot (although it does have one) but for the way Wharton uses language and for the images he creates with his words.
This is a book that is more dream than novel. It tells the story of a young man who tumbles into a crevasse in a glacier in the Rocky Mountains. Dangling upside down in an icy bluness waiting to be rescued by his climbing companions he sees an angel (identifiable by the wings) frozen into the ice beside him. He is mesmerized, and after his rescue becomes obsessed with the glacier, spending his life climbing it, waiting for it to move down the valley, to melt...to disgorge the angel so he can study it.
The story spans many years and follows (loosely) the Victorian exploration and opening up of the Canadian Rockies with a tough-minded lady moutaineer, a doctor, moutain guides, hotel managers etc. impinging in a variety of ways on the young mans life as he waits and grows older. There is a love story embedded in the novel but this is really a tale of obsession. The story floats, dreamlike - mirroring the way the angel 'floats' eternally in the ice. It is not a linear read.
I like it but I don't think it's for everyone.

The Only Boy in the World: A Father Explores the Mysteries of Autism
The Only Boy in the World: A Father Explores the Mysteries of Autism
by Michael Blastland
Edition: Paperback
Price: CDN$ 13.51
16 used & new from CDN$ 0.91

5.0 out of 5 stars A very thought-provoking read, April 5 2009
This is a book that examines the life of a very singular individual and in so doing explores major philosophical ideas about what exactly defines humanity - what is it that makes us human.
Blastland writes about his 10-year-old son Joe, who has severe, classic autism. He gives a very clear and moving picture of what daily life is like for someone caring for such an individual. Blastland' gives us evidence in detailed anecdotes (sometimes moving, sometimes amusing yet heart-wrenching) to support his thesis that to all intents and purposes, Joe is "the only boy in the world" because he is `mind-blind'...that is he cannot conceive of other people as having a mind. For Joe, people are no different to other animate and even inanimate objects in his world. Joe's own mind is the only mind he has ever met. Joe is alone in a very deep sense of the word.
Having tried to understand the terrible isolation Joe lives in, Blastland then asks the following question. If understanding another's point-of-view, being able to empathise, understand, relate to other individuals makes us human, does this mean Joe is in some sense not human? Blastland explores this painful question whilst painting a moving and always loving portrait of his son.
This is a book rooted in a harsh reality but it asks some deeply spiritual questions and offers alternate viewpoints. It is though-provoking and one of the best books I have read on this subject. It is the book that came closest to helping me understand what life might be like for an autist. Highly recommended.

The Wolves In The Walls
The Wolves In The Walls
by Neil Gaiman
Edition: Paperback
Price: CDN$ 7.59
36 used & new from CDN$ 0.90

5.0 out of 5 stars A Visual feast!, April 5 2009
Neil Gaiman writes wonderful books for children with very sophisticated illustrations that I love! He uses many different art techniques, photo montages, collages, pen-and-ink drawings and painting to render the unsettling and often bizarre world of a child's imagination. In this book I particularly like the hidden faces of the wolves in the clouds.
The story features Lucy and her cuddly pig who can hear wolves living in the walls of the house. Lucy tries to warn her family, but no one believes her. Her tuba-playing father thinks she has an overactive imagination, her jam-making mother says it's rats, her brother knows it's bats but they all tell her that "when the wolves come out of the walls, it's all over."
Well the wolves do come out of the walls and they are freaky and scary and funny and portrayed with a keen sense of the fantastic. And it is all over - until Lucy comes up with a solution.
This is sold as a children's book but, as with all Gaiman's books, the artwork makes it much, much more. It's scary and quirky and funky and witty.
And...a huge visual feast.

The Big Year: A Tale of Man, Nature, and Fowl Obsession
The Big Year: A Tale of Man, Nature, and Fowl Obsession
by Mark Obmascik
Edition: Paperback
Price: CDN$ 14.43
53 used & new from CDN$ 0.01

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars It's birding Jim, but not as we know it!, April 4 2009
This is a book about obsession.
Mark Obmascik tells the story of three birders - Greg Miller, Sandy Komito and Al Levantin - who take this most mild-mannered of hobbies to a new level in their desire to smash the existing record for a Big Year. A Big Year is a single year in which a birder aims to see as many north American birds as possible and in 1998, the number to beat was well over 700. There are no prizes, no huge international recognition, no kudos or accolades beyond obscure birding circles...no reason to do this...unless you're obsessed by birds.
The exploits of these three guys are more of an extreme sport than the genteel pastime involving binoculars and sanwiches that birding is usually considered to be. These guys are prepared to charter helicopters to fly snowy peaks after Himalayan snowcocks, throw up over the back of ocean-going vessels to chase pelagic birds that never come to shore, yomp across frozen mud in freezing sleet on the remote island of Attu to see rarities blown off-course by winter storms, and canoe through alligator-infested swamps after flamingos. It's birding Jim, but not as we know it!
The book is easy to read. Obmascik has stuck a good balance between drawing portraits of the three men, providing details about the birds and the locations they are found and he doesn't over-emphasise the lunacy of the pursuit...he doesn't need to! I'm only a on-off, kitchen-window kind of a birder but I enjoyed this book.

The Magic Toyshop
The Magic Toyshop
by Angela Carter
Edition: Paperback
Price: CDN$ 14.08
31 used & new from CDN$ 4.38

5.0 out of 5 stars Come into my parlour, April 2 2009
This review is from: The Magic Toyshop (Paperback)
Angela Carter wrote seriously weird yet truly captivating and intelligent magical realism. This was her second book. It is the heroine Melanie's coming of age story packaged in a fairytale-like sense of unreality.

Melanie and her two siblings are suddenly orphaned at the very beginning of the novel and ripped from their genteel upper-class way of life to live in the slums of a large city with their brutal Uncle Philip (a toymaker) and their silent Aunt Margaret.

Melanie finds herself increasingly drawn to the young man Finn who has the bedroom next to hers. He is a quietly subversive, freakish character who sides with Melanie in her growing dislike of Uncle Phillip. The household is full of submerged tension that centres around Aunt Margaret and which comes to a head when Melanie is forced to play the part of Leida in Uncle Phillips dark puppet version of Leida and the Swan. Melanie is metaphorially raped, Finn defies his uncle to come to her rescue and the repressed members of Uncle Phillips swiftly family spiral into chaos.

The ending is a little unexpected (like a train wreck when the rails run out!)and not as well controlled as the rest of the novel but this is a book you read for images, ideas and spectacular use of language as much as for the plot.

Carter excelled at writing bizzare details that fascinate at the same time as they repell...and this makes for a compelling read. This is a book I first read in my early twenties and one I re-read every couple of years or so and always find something new.

I Heard the Owl Call My Name
I Heard the Owl Call My Name
by Margaret Craven
Edition: Paperback
22 used & new from CDN$ 0.01

4.0 out of 5 stars "The past is a foreign country, they do things differently there.", April 2 2009
I read this in an original beautiful 1967 paperback original version. The cover features iconic artwork in gold and black with a clean simplicity of design.It is very much a book of it's time (1967) but surprisingly perceptive about the negative effects of the white man's incursions on First Nations traditions and culture.

A young priest about to die (though he doesn't know it) is assigned to a remote First Nation's village on the NW coast of Canada. Unlike the school teacher he finds there, Mark Brian makes few judgements or assumptions about the people of the village but tries to be open to their customs and way of life. He discovers that the ancient myths and traditions usually passed from generation to generation are being forgotten because the youth of the village are being lured away by the false glamour of life of the big cities - though what they often find there is only trouble and despair.
The writing is sparse and beautiful transmitting a real flavour of the West Coast. The descriptions of the landscape are haunting and the whole book is infused with a deep sense of melancholy, not only because of it's plot but also because it reads like a lament for something already vanishing forty years ago when the book was written and which is now irretrievable.

Builders of the Pacific Coast
Builders of the Pacific Coast
by Lloyd Kahn
Edition: Paperback
Price: CDN$ 20.03
35 used & new from CDN$ 14.80

3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars A book to return to again and again, April 1 2009
This is a beautiful book full of pictures. There is some writing but it's the pictures that really make this book! The many photographs showcase some of the incredible organic buildings that you find along the North American west coast. Many of the homes are on the tiny islands just off the coast of Canada.
Built from driftwood, cedar, recycled materials and imagination these are homes to dream about. The neat thing is these dwellings are mostly not the huge fancy houses(though a few are featured) but are small homes built by people who love to build and who are not interested in raking in big bucks. For many of these builders their chief love in life is...surfing!
Kahn writes in an intimate chatty style that makes you feel you might have met the builders whose work he showcases, probably on a beach somewhere. And his interest in all things quirky and unusual mean that this reads like a book written by a favourite eccentic uncle... one who takes stunning photos.
This is a book to dip into and out of and then lie on a beach in the sun and daydream about - everyone I have shown it to scuttled off into a corner and pored over it for at least half an hour before reluctantly handing it back and vowing to go out and buy it.

Ja No Man: Growing Up White in Apartheid Era South Africa
Ja No Man: Growing Up White in Apartheid Era South Africa
by Richard Poplak
Edition: Paperback
Price: CDN$ 13.14
6 used & new from CDN$ 13.14

2 of 3 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Reflecting on Apartheid, April 1 2009
I read this book in a couple of evenings and really liked it. It is the account of a middle-class white boy's childhood and adolescence in 1970's/80's08 South Africa. Poplak brilliantly steers a line between hilarity and poignancy. He recreates how unlikely and surreal everyday life there could be. He highlights the absurdities of the aparthaid sytem and the corruption of politicians who created and perpetuated it, shedding light on the political realities of a brutal regime through his stories of the hilarious events of his boyhood. So much of his experience is familiar to anyone who grew up in Western Society in the 1980's (the music, the clothing, the TV shows) and yet the undercurrents of a repressive and psychotic government make his experience oddly alien. This was a fascinating read.
If you like Cry the Beloved Country by Alan Paton, Don't Let's Go to the Dogs Tonight by Alexander Fuller or Disgrace by JM Coetze ...then try this.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3