K. Weld

It's Still An Overwhelming Story, July 8 2004

First, I would like to comment on language. Skip to the asterisks to by-pass a mild rant.

Words are used to convey ideas. No word in and of itself is "bad", and curse words are frequently (and commonly) used to express intensity, disdain, passion, et al. Frankly, anyone who would condemn a story because the language contained within it is living in a fantasy world whose bubble will pop (one can only hope permanently) the first time they bump into something real.
This book, like all the others, contains language that your mommy wouldn't like. People who have grown up don't let this bother them, while others plant their heads under the blanket and hope the boogie knights don't come for… Read more

One Voice Among Thousands..., July 8 2004

Better late than never, yes?

Say "Yes" and let's move on.

I highly respect Martin's skill with defining and separating the individuals within the world. From Sansa Stark's vapid existence of unending weakness to Arya Stark's rebellion against her gender role, to addressing the weaknesses of adhering without question to ethics and the penalties for living without any code at all, Martin has managed to put into words whole perspectives on life without coming across as preachy.

That's an accomplishment, and one I am utterly overwhelmed by.

This book is both subtle and obvious, depending on where you are in the story and how much one pays attention. There is simply no way for… Read more

A great read, but short of 5 stars., Jan 7 2004

The Grand Crusade... first off, it's an accurate title. Michael takes his time reintroducing the characters, and while I understand why writers do that, I'm not convinced it needs to be done in a limited series (this is presumably the last book).
As usual, I enjoyed Michael's narrative immensely. The clarity with which he describes not only combat scenes but entire battles is startling, especially since it's easy to read. Possibly the most appreciated element, which Michael uses well, is his inclusion of descriptions of some of the nastier wounds that people take. The kind of thing that makes the reader realize how gory battle really can be.

If you're looking for the revival of Will… Read more