biss Livres en français boutiques-francophones Protegez vos photos et videos personnelles snsflyour Furniture Nouveau Kindle Paperwhite Films selection Jazz, Blues et musique actuelle Exercice Tools ca_ty_gno

Commentaires des clients

3,8 sur 5 étoiles13
3,8 sur 5 étoiles
Votre évaluation(Effacer)Évaluez cet article

Un problème s'est produit lors du filtrage des commentaires. Veuillez réessayer plus tard.

James Rollins is not a bad writer. By now I must have given a try to most of his books - and discovered the same weaknesses to almost all of them: he aims too high for his writing wingspan; his suspense is constantly peaking so that, when the big moments do come, they fail to convey the climaxing feeling; and his science gets weaker and weaker.

MICHAEL CRICHTON used to be able to both educate on cutting-edge scientific theories and yarn a good story at the same time (not with his latest couple of novels I am afraid though). James Rollins probably gets impressed by new concepts, feels they could help the credibility of his fiction - and then does not know how to use them properly.

I remember in SANDSTORM, he used bucky-balls (60-carbon atoms spherical crystals) to enclose ancient...anti-matter - and then used it, all in all, to..propel a boat across a subterranean lake and cause a couple of minor explosions.

BLACK ORDER suffers from similar shortcomings: there is one narrative peak after the other and this never lets the story unfold; and he scrapes up quantum effects on evolution only to create a bunch of superhumans and enlarged animals.
By the way, to anyone who has studied even one semester of Evolutionary Biology, the concept is a B-Movie gimmick: evolution can only move forward (yes, even if the resulting organism seems more "primitive"). Even if it were a possibility, it would probably need more than ...a few days - say, a few MILLION years.

I am willing to suspend my disbelief when reading a work of fiction: after all, good fiction does not have to be real. This, however, sticks out too much to ignore.

Give one of his other books a try instead. AMAZONIA was good and ICEHUNT even better.
0CommentaireCette évaluation a-t-elle été utile pour vous?OuiNonSignaler un abus
le 19 juillet 2007
There are very few authors whose books I have to go buy the day they come out, but James Rollins is one of those authors (Patterson used to be but no more). I fell in love with this author two years ago when I started reading my husband's copy of "Sandstorm," I was hooked from the first page. With "Black Order" Rollins has taken the action, suspense, and non stop thrills up another notch. I wont go over all the plot details as that has already been done enough here, plus it just ruins the surprises (be careful of some of the other reviews, I think they give too much away). In this one Rollins brings back Sigma force led by Painter Crowe and Grayson Pierce, then mixes the descendants of Heinrich Himmler, quantum mechanics, theories of evolution and intelligent design, and in includes a dash of spirituality for a wildly fun read. This may seem like a stretch but he makes it all work! The twists and turns will keep you guessing while the heart pounding action will keep you turning the pages! Fans of Cussler, Crichton, and Dan Brown should all enjoy this book. And I also have to recommend "Tourist in the Yucatan," a thriller adventure that has become a cult classic!
0CommentaireCette évaluation a-t-elle été utile pour vous?OuiNonSignaler un abus
le 13 juillet 2007
It's not all bad. As a matter of fact it's an A for plot bunnies and storytelling, even if the ending stumbles into outright sanctimony--though much enjoyment can be derived from imagining how Jewish people everywhere would react if they found out that their Messiah is not just a Catholic priest, but a *Polish* Catholic priest to boot. Oi gevalt! The irony is without doubt unintentional on the part of the author. His grasp of World War II history doesn't extend far enough. (Adolf Hitler was captured? When? And by whom?)

Characterization is a mixed bag throughout. Some of the characters (often the minor players) are well-drawn and credible. Others plain defy the reader's willingness to suspend his or her disbelief. For instance, Sigma Force agent Gray Pierce not only has studied multiple religions and other fields of spiritual belief but also is a biologist and physicist; not to mention the fact that, for no apparent reason, he seems to be fluent in such relatively obscure languages as Danish and Afrikaans. Between all the studying the man must be putting in, one wonders when he finds the time to do his agenting.

Stylistically, too, the book has its problems. Rollins can spin a yarn, no doubt about it, but there are far too many instances where it's glaringly obvious that he's been fishing for a fancy word, hit the dictionary or thesaurus, and proceeded to create a malapropism. Which, incidentally, raises the question of how a publisher as reputable as Harper Collins can employ editors who fail to pick up on this and a great many other problems.

At the end of the day, the downfall of the book lies in its execution. See, the trouble with a techno thriller always is the *techno* part (not unlike that pesky science bit in *science* fiction). In order to make that believable, an author has to do the necessary homework. Mr. Rollins has signally failed to do his. It's all the worse, because the entire premise of the book is based on quantum physics--not a field that can be digested by taking in a pop-sci volume in passing, which seems to be exactly what Rollins deems sufficient. And so the infamous double-slot experiment (generally to be found in the 'Introduction' to every Quantum Mechanics 101 textbook ever written) somehow, and quite erroneously, serves as explanation of how quantum physics influence evolution. Along the way, he misrepresents Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle as well as Heisenberg himself and invents whole new birthplaces for major proponents in the field (while Erwin Schroedinger did in fact hold dual nationality, neither of his passports were German).

As a matter of fact, the whole thing gets so implausible that it turns out to be quite funny. What isn't funny in the slightest, however, is the attitude behind it, because ultimately it reveals a profound disrespect for the reader (yes, that would be the same person who pays Mr. Rollins's royalties). The assumption that proper research is unnecessary because the reader won't notice anyway is unacceptable. In fact, some of us even are capable of realizing that Rollins's copious offerings in German are amateurish enough to make one's eyes water (there are such things as native speakers out there, sir).

If you're looking for a tight, plausible, thoroughly researched techno thriller based on quantum physics, this isn't it. For anyone who'd like to see how it should be done, I recommend 'Timelines' by Michael Crichton.
0CommentaireCette évaluation a-t-elle été utile pour vous?OuiNonSignaler un abus
le 11 août 2006
James Rollins' books always have intriguing and exciting storylines, and Black Order is no exception! The book grabs you from page one and doesn't let go. Black Order is James' third book featuring Sigma Force (the others being Sandstorm and Map Of Bones). It's premise goes back to WWII and the Nazis, their desire for the Aryan race, and their endeavour to create the perfect human. It then fast-forwards to present day where this research is still going on, with horrific results. Black Order is a page-turning thriller, and impossible to put down! I thoroughly enjoyed the book and highly recommend it to all thriller fans. If you like this book please read other books by James Rollins as they're all fantastic.
0CommentaireCette évaluation a-t-elle été utile pour vous?OuiNonSignaler un abus
le 10 juin 2007
This is literally one of the best novel I've ever read. The novel Black Order deals with events after WWII, Darwin's evolution theory, and origin of life. The novel starts with events dealing with the aftermath of WWII, giving the reader a 'hook', a sense of wanting to read forth. Throughout the novel Rollins switches between events occurring in South Africa, the Himalayas in Tibet, and Copenhagen, Denmark. Rollins manages to tie three seemingly unrelated events into this well plotted storyline. Each chapter is more interested and fascinating then the last. Black Order will have you reading till the early morning. Excellent for those that enjoy mystery, action, and adventure thrillers. Highly recommended.
0CommentaireCette évaluation a-t-elle été utile pour vous?OuiNonSignaler un abus
le 30 octobre 2007
What an incredible book. Once you start reading it, you won't be able to set it down. I even got yelled at by my boss for reading the book on company time. I've read it 4 times and each time is like the first time. There is alot of information to process so get ready be blown away. It's awsome. Also, if you missed reading Tino Georgiou's masterpiece--The Fates, go and read it.
0CommentaireCette évaluation a-t-elle été utile pour vous?OuiNonSignaler un abus
le 17 juillet 2007
The Black Order by James Rollins took me by surprise. I hadn't read any other book by this author before and decided to buy it and read it on my holidays to Europe. What a fantastic book full of suspence, mystery, surprise,...literally made you hold your breath in case you miss something.
Very good story line (although of course fiction!!). Time will pass by pleasantly.
0CommentaireCette évaluation a-t-elle été utile pour vous?OuiNonSignaler un abus
le 3 septembre 2015
Very good read in my opinion...really liked the historical background and the scientific information and debate about "the question of intelligent design versus evolution". Brilliant and well-done!
0CommentaireCette évaluation a-t-elle été utile pour vous?OuiNonSignaler un abus
le 15 octobre 2014
Reads a bit like a B Horror movie - Literally 'all-over the place', with too many villains and monsters, all wrapped up in post-Nazi eugenics and quantum apocalyptic dread
0CommentaireCette évaluation a-t-elle été utile pour vous?OuiNonSignaler un abus
le 4 mai 2014
But once it gets going, tough not to finish. I was wondering at first if I should finish the book, but at one point, I just kept going and was intrigued to see the end.
0CommentaireCette évaluation a-t-elle été utile pour vous?OuiNonSignaler un abus