Commentaire positif le plus utile
5 sur 5 personnes ont trouvé le commentaire suivant utile
Somes the cure is worse than the condition
le 4 février 2011
I casually put this book on a list of books to read a while back and got a hold of it just a week after having a "bad" reaction to an anti-depressant, and wish I had read this book much earlier. There is significant evidence, as detailed in the book, that many common anti-depressants, psychotics, anxiety, bi-bolor have poor long term outcomes vs. nonmedicated sufferers, which is surprising. I had bought somewhat into the chemical imbalance theory of these disorders, but this books indicates that there is little evidence for this. In fact, a prime criticism of this book is that it doesn't mount much of a defence for the other side, doesn't overview the evidence as to why people believed that these medicines worked. Partly that's because this evidence comes in the form of people do worse when taken off the medication, which can be easily explained given how the brain adapts. Perhaps it's also because the evidence doesn't exist. It'd be interesting to see some rebuttals along more concrete lines, with references, etc., rather than vague allusions to "the complexity" of the problem.