biss Livres en français boutiques-francophones Protegez vos photos et videos personnelles vd2016beauty Furniture Nouveau Kindle Paperwhite Films selection Jazz, Blues et musique actuelle Exercice ca_ty_gno Tools

Commentaires des clients

4,7 sur 5 étoiles54
4,7 sur 5 étoiles
Format: HardcoverModifier
Votre évaluation(Effacer)Évaluez cet article

Un problème s'est produit lors du filtrage des commentaires. Veuillez réessayer plus tard.

Affichage de 1-2 sur 2 commentaires(3 étoiles). Afficher tous les commentaires
le 4 décembre 2003
This book gets so much praise, it makes me want to write a few words about it myself. I bought this after reading a lot of positive reviews, and had in mind of giving it away for Christmas present. There has got to be something good about a book that everybody gives best grades, right?
But when I read it, I think maybe it gets all this praise just because it is a graphic novel showing big amition. It is well drawn and very many pages. To people with a big interest in graphic novels, this is of course a big thing. Comics fans probably has been waiting for a book like this to come out. A big, well drawn book with an epic with depth and emotion, suitable to convincing non-belivers about the medium's greatness.
But I want to say, that it does not necessarily appeal to everyone. The story is a bit sentimental and predictable. What does the story tell us? That it is hard growing up, OK. Some people who likes Daniel Clowe's "Ghost World" and may find Thompson's version of teenage angst a bit naïve and puppy eyed in comparison.
This is a pretty nice story, with neat artwork. I'm just trying to point out, that there is room for a lot of different tastes and directions in the art form of graphic novels. Nowadays I think many people doesn't have too much prejudice about comics - the media isn't the important thing, but the content is. Personally I like storys like Adrian Tomine's and Daniel Clowes', artists who may have more in common with film directors like Todd Solondz and Paul Thomas Anderson than with Craig Thompson. I'm not saying Clowes should be the measure to all new comics, but in comparison Thompson's story here reminds me more of some made for TV harmless drama.
What I mean is, just try to forget about the medium, and what you have here is a predictable and sweet, traditional and quite nice story about growing up, that doesn't say anything new unless you haven't read to many stories about growing up.Or, of course, if you're about to grow up yourself. If I wanted to persuade any of my friends that graphic novels are't nessecarily boring, this is actually not my choice of book to give them.
0CommentaireCette évaluation a-t-elle été utile pour vous?OuiNonSignaler un abus
le 30 janvier 2004
Craig Thompson is a master storyteller and exceptional artist. What's unfortunate is that Craig, like most in his medium, paints (or draws) a sketchy two dimensional portrait of Christianity and Christians themselves.
This book sucked me in completely and I could not put it down. I ran the gamut of emotions. I could relate with the characters and their plights. I too was raised in a Christian home and made the annual trips with my youth group. I too met my first love at church camp, and I too felt like an outsider. I even admired how the main character questioned his faith, as I had during that time in my life. However, as the book progressed it became apparent that this was yet another trashing and thrashing of the Christian faith. What Craig and others forget is that Christianity, like all other faiths, is practiced by people. Sinful, self centered and yes, (even)critical people. If Craig is drawing on past experiences, then I feel sorry for him. The events portrayed are terrible, and the things programmed early on in his life were a teespoon of truth mixed with a lot of opinion. While questioning ones faith is perfectly normal, one should use the oportunity to speak to as many people as possible, read and pray. Not to simply accept the words of one very misguided pastor and Sunday school teacher.
This book concreted my feet in my faith rather than question it which was an intended purpose IMHO.
All of these issues aside, the book was incredibly well written and executed.
0Commentaire4 sur 7 personnes ont trouvé cela utile. Cette évaluation a-t-elle été utile pour vous?OuiNonSignaler un abus

Les clients ont également vu ces articles

32,08 $
17,58 $
17,75 $
19,01 $